Collingwood Fixture 2008

Collingwood Fixture 2008

Thursday, April 16, 2009

[AFL-Review] AFL Round 3

AFL Round 3

 

Yes! I've done it, a report that appears after the preview of the following round. It's been my ambition . . . sorry, went away for an extended Easter and had a lazy but enjoyable time. Except when I went to the footy.

 

At the MCG:

Geelong      2.3   10.6   11.11   18.14.122

Collingwood  5.5    5.9    8.15   13.17.95                    

 

The idea of the Maggies being the Cats' nemesis has received a battering over the last month. Jahlong thumped the Poise in the NAB Cup final and followed up with an easy-enough win here. Poi fans would point to their winning first term and some appalling goal-kicking inaccuracy which wasted a good third quarter. But that ignores the fact they were thoroughly out-played in the second term and the last too. And have a few players down on form - is there any danger of Travis Cloke getting a kick? In selection the Cats made three changes to the side victorious over the Tiges, they reckon Brad Ottens (strained medial ligament) will only miss 2 or 3 games now, while Simon Hogan and Ryan Gamble were dropped. Hogan in fact debuted last week, he's from Warrnambool. Incoming were back-up ruckman Trent West and small forwards Mathew Stokes and Shannon Byrnes. One change for the Pies, Dale Thomas returning at the expense of Alan Toovey. 

 

Game started in dream fashion for the Pies. Strong tackling pressure forced the Cats into a series of retreating handballs until they lost the ball and Alan Didak cantered into the sticks to poke it through. It proved the first-quarter pattern as the Maggies swarmed 'round the ball. "In every shot on the TV you see more Collingwood players than Geelong ones," said commentator Leigh Matthews. Did he coach by watching TV in the box? The Pies had Leigh Brown line up at full-forward, 'tagging' Matthew Scarlett; coulda been a match-winning move if the ex-Kanga Brown had kicked straight. He missed the first of several shots, from 15m following a good, juggled mark. But on the Cats' kick-in one of many bizarre rules the AFL has introduced brought the Pies a goal, Geelong's runner (ex-Tige Duncan Kellaway) was inside the 50m zone. This resulted in a free to the Pies on the attacking 50m line, the ball was fed wide to Shannon Cox who roosted it through on-the-run. The Cats responded, Paul Chapman passed for leading Gary Ablett to mark strongly in front of the taller Nick Maxwell and boot truly. Ablett started at full-forward, as coach 'Bomber' Thompson had suggested would happen more often this season. Medhurst missed for the Poise before Ablett caught Heath Shaw with a strong tackle, 'bawl' it was and the ump allowed a generous advantage for Mathew Stokes to run clear and slot an easy one. The Poise led by 2 points. Tight for a while before the Pies spurted clear at the end of the term. A rapid rebound was completed by Medhurst's gather and pass to unattended Dayne Beams, he goaled. Soon Dane Swan drove the Maggies forward, looking for Dale Thomas, he couldn't mark but Thomas roved his own contest and snapped a major. Leigh Brown missed with a free-kick before the Pies bagged another, Thomas punted to the 'square where John Anthony clutched a well-judged grab at the back of the pack. Bit of hands-in-the-back went unpunished and Anthony popped it through. The Poise led by 20 points at the first break.

 

Leigh Brown missed for a third time early in the second stanza, none of the shots difficult. The Cats fired back into it, led by Chapman, Jimmy Bartel and forward Steve Johnson. But all over, the Cats moved the ball with great speed and skill. A terrific move from the kick-in of the Brown point ended with Chapman lobbing a handball for racing David Wojcinski to hammer a sausage. Under-pressure Pie backman Simon Prestigiacomo hacked a clearing kick straight to some Cat, the ball went to Bartel and his pass found Stokes alone for a mark and goal. The Pu55ies won the following centre-clearance and a free to Johnson, his shot postered. A bit later Chapman was biffed high by Nathan Brown at a ball-up, a free-kick and a 50m penalty was added as Heath Shaw came in and shoved the umpire gently in the shoulder. Dunno why he did that, Shaw was reported as well and he's since been fined and suspended for one game. Chapman majored from point-blank, reducing the Pie lead to 2 points. Johnson was flattened by Maxwell off-the-ball (two games for the Pie skipper) and Josh Fraser missed poorly from 30m, right in front as the Pies began to get rattled. Byrnes intercepted a telegraphed Cox kick and punted the Catters into attack, Travis Varcoe did very well to win the ball, swap handballs with Ablett and Varcoe poked a goal. Cam Mooney led long to mark in the centre-square and dish off a handpass to Chapman, he passed noicely for leading Johnson to grab and convert. Lockyer scored a behind for the Poise before Cat Steve Johnson did very well at a throw-in, diving to win possession and fire a handpass which led to a goal for Varcoe. A bit later Shaw shanked a clearing kick on-the-full and Johnson's quickly-taken free allowed leading Tom Hawkins to mark ahead of Nathan Brown, Hawkins majored and the Cats led by 21 points. A ridiculous newspaper column last week declared Hawkins a failure. He's 20 years old and played 20 games. The Catters won the following centre-clearance, Hawkins clutched a strong grab again and missed from a tough angle. But the Cats finished off well, Chapman galloped forward and passed wide to Johnson, he lined-up before stabbing a pass back to unopposed Chapman, who played-on and thumped it through. Cats by 27 points at the long break, eight goals to none for the second korter. To complete the terrible half-hour for the Pies their Ben Johnson limped off with a fractured leg, his night and possibly season were over.

 

Into the third and the Cats dominated the early minutes but Mooney and Johnson missed shots. The Pies narrowed the gap and ended their goal-drought after Medhurst leaped for a good mark over taller Cat Harry Taylor and booted truly. Leigh Brown showed some great skill to scoop a loose ball and pass smartly to Lockyer, but he missed weakly. The Cats moved swiftly downfield from the kick-in and Steve Johnson had a goal-square free-kick for O'Bree's holding, Johnson majored and the Pu55ies led by 28 points. The Pies lifted though, rediscovering some of the pressure and moving the ball more slickly. But they cruelled it in front of the sticks. Didak and Beams kicked points, at the other end Cat Johnson was shoved face-first in to the turf by O'Brien, hard enough to break his nose, possibly. It certainly bled a lot. That wasn't a free-kick though, to general disbelief (Johnson's especially). Didak kicked another Pie behind and Marty Clarke ran relentlessly to start and end a move from half-back, but he missed a set shot as well. The Poise got one finally, Medhurst turned smartly and found leading Thomas with a pass, Thomas chipped ahead for lurking Brad Dick to mark and convert. A hard-to-believe, skilful pick-up and handpass from Prestigiacomo found Leigh Brown in space and he finally managed to kick straight from distance, the Pies'd narrowed the deficit to 15 points as McAvaney rumbled "they're coming!" in that throaty, drop-an-octave 'dramatic' voice he uses. But Travis Cloke, quiet, shanked a very soft free-kick out-of-bounds and Thomas and Fraser proceeded to kick behinds from set-shots. Fraser's, after the siren, was particularly deflating for Poi fans as the Cats led by 14 points at the final change. Bomber could be seen giving his lads a stern word and the Catters killed off the Maggies with three quick goals to start the final Mario. Wojcinski sped clear of a ball-up and kicked long, the pill spilled off Mooney's hands and Johnson was there to soccer it through left-footedly. Then Ablett - big second half - found leading Johnson for a grab, he played on, Mooney tapped-on and Hawkins handballed for Byrnes to snap a major. A minute later Bartel's strong defensive pack-mark initiated a rebound move, Byrnes punted long and Mooney roved his own contest to snap another Cat sausage (mmmm, Cat sausage). The Pu55ies led by 32 points with barely 5 minutes gone for the term. The Pies hung in there, Fraser missed yet another set-shot before a good, sharp move ended with 'Neon' Leon Davis stabbing a low kick for full points. But Geelers scored the next two, Chapman goaled after being awarded a mark from a Johnson pass which travelled about 10m, then Hawkins clutched a strong goal-square mark against two Poise and booted a major. Geelong led by 38 points and the heat went outta the game, but lots more goals were scored. The Poise had the next two, Lockyer finally converting from a mark and Medhurst got one after juggling a mark on-the-lead and being dragged down by Wojcinski, adding a 50m penalty. Chapman bagged his fourth after dropping a mark but Varcoe swept up the ball with great skill and handballed back to Chappy so he could dob it. Some fairly lazy Cat efforts allowed Fraser to bag one at last, then Clarke found Medhurst with a pass and 'Steak Knives' scored full points with a tremendous kick. He was the best Pie forward on the night. The Pies hovered 20 points behind with about 4 minutes remaining, but the Cats had the final six-pointer when Chapman set one up for Max Rooke.

 

Big game from Paul Chapman (35 disposals, 7 marks, 4 goals) with great efforts from Steve Johnson again (19 touches, 6 marks, 3 goals) and Jimmy Bartel (28 possies, 9 marks). Gary Ablett (37 touches, 7 marks, a goal) started slowly but had a big second half when playing more on-the-ball, in attack Travis Varcoe (16 disposals, 2 goals) showed great skill and did some very good things. Corey Enright (24 touches, 7 marks) and Joel Selwood (26 possies) were solid contributors. Tom Hawkins and Mathew Stokes booted 2 goals each. For the Poise ball-hunter Dane Swan (30 possessions, 8 marks) and loping wingman Scott Pendlebury (25 disposals) played well, Paul Medhurst (16 touches, 8 marks, 3 goals) was a useful forward and Shannon Cox (22 possies, a goal) did a decent job carrying the ball from defence. The press was happy with Josh Fraser (19 touches, 8 marks, 22 hit-outs) but his return of 1.3 was frustrating. Junior Dayne Beams (21 disposals, 9 marks, a goal) was okay. Mick Malthouse played the eccentric again, declaring Geelong too good for his Poise. "We played a very good side and they made us pay dearly," Malthouse said after the match. "I'm not going to blame shots on goal, Geelong were just better than us . . . Geelong are a very good football side. Geelong, playing at their absolute best and us at our absolute best; they'll beat us because they're better than us - and they'll beat 14 other clubs. Whether they beat Hawthorn is another thing, I suppose." Perhaps he can't add up. Mick went on to, in fact, blame the goal-kicking. "We had 19 set shots [and] we kicked seven. I can't remember Leigh (Brown) having 19 shots [at goal] but you'd like those to be kicked. Especially [because] he's a reliable kick, generally, and for him to miss his first three is disappointing for him and for us." Mark 'Bomber' Thompson was frustrated by the Pu55ies' within-game inconsistency. "That's just footy at the start of the year and it's probably the hardest period to play in," he said. "There's certainly going to be fluctuations in footy. We've still got a lot of footy left. It's only round three . . . I was very happy with half of it and very angry for the other half . . . At half time I told them to stay on the job and play the ultimate team game and play the ultimate team structure."

 

At Docklands:

St. Kilda   5.2   15.2   20.7   25.11.161

West Coast  2.4    4.5    9.7     9.10.64

 

The Saints franked their early season form by absolutely smashing the Weegs at Docklands. Some people thought this might be a good game, following on from the Eegs' big win last weekend. But Sinkilda's hard tackling pressure and strong forward line-up saw the Weegs beaten very early and easily. Both sides were unchanged following round two wins, my apologies to Weegle David Wirrpanda as he missed last week (and this, and the next couple maybe) with a hamstring injury, he wasn't dropped as I said.

 

The early stages were close-ish. The Saints started Brendon Goddard in a forward-pocket and it proved a very successful move as he bagged four first-quarter goals. Goddard had two sausages within the opening four minutes, the first came as Nick Riewoldt led wide to collect Nick Dal Santo's wayward pass and handball inboard to Clint Jones, he stabbed a pass for leading Goddard to mark and steer through from a tight angle. The Stainers won the following centre-break and a cool series of handballs was completed by Leigh Montagna's pass to a diving Goddard, who marked and converted again. The Weegs replied presently, Tyson Stenglein lobbed a punt forward from a ball-up and Adam Hunter, between two Saints, was awarded a mystery free. Hands-in-the-back, mebbe, Hunter majored. A few minutes later Mark LeCras slotted following a decent mark of Ben McKinley's kick and scores were level. But Sinkilda's Luke Ball won the following centre-clearance with a great blind-turn and his kick was marked by Goddard again, too wily for young opponent Mitch Brown. Goddard booted his third, Weegs Priddis, Cox and Fletcher proceeded to kick behinds before Goddard's fourth sausage arrived as he roved a big pack 20m out and stabbed it home. The Saints led by 9 points. Riewoldt kicked a behind before Justin Koschitzke emerged, Riewoldt led long into the centre to mark and dishoff to Hayes, who passed for leading Koschitzke to mark and convert. The Stainers led 16 points at korter-time.

 

They really put the hammer down in the second. LeCras's early goal, a free for held back by Gilbert, narrowed the gap to 10 points but the Saints rammed through four goals in the next eight minutes, dominating contested ball and unafraid to kick to contests as a result. Ruckman Steven King was gifted the first, marking Geary's pass 35m out on a tricky angle, King was clattered by late-arriving Stenglein (stupid stuff) and duly majored from a point-blank shot following the 50m penalty. Montagna bagged one after brilliantly snaffling Weeg Mackenzie's handpass, I think it was, then Koschitzke scooped up James Gwilt's under-hit pass, wheeled about and blasted it home from 50m, another great goal. Sinkilda's Jones won the following centre-clearance and, after some handballs about, Jarryn Geary juggled an excellent one-handed mark with Brett Jones all over him. Geary majored and the Saints led by 34 points. A LeCras behind broke the run before Stephen Milne got in on the act, Eegle Embley hacked a clearing punt straight to Montagna who drove it back, Koschitzke flew too early and missed the ball but lurking Milne gathered and dribbled it through. The Saints began to lairize as Koschitzke led to mark on the 50m line and handball off to Goddard, he passed to Riewoldt, leading into the pocket, whose quick handball saw Dal Santo thread it through off one step. Saints by 45 points. LeCras managed a sausage roll for the Weevils at this point, Gwilt coughed up possession in a tackle and Adam Selwood collected the loose ball, LeCras gathered Selwood's grubbered pass and snapped truly. But the Saints completed the job with another four-goal salvo in time-on. Andrew McQualter snapped one with some great roving after Koschitzke absolutely crashed through a pack, killing some Eeg backman. Shoulda been a free to him. Koschitzke himself then booted one, set up by Riewoldt's brilliant interception of a cross-goal kick from Mark Nicoski. The Stains won the following centre-clearance and Gwilt took a strong overhead grab of Dal Santo's pass, Gwilt then chipped a kick for ex-Weeg Michael Gardiner to mark and punt truly. The Sainters' ten-goal quarter was completed by Weeg skipper Darren Glass turning over in tackle and Milne gratefully accepting Geary's handball to snap it through. Stinkilda led by 63 points at half-time and it was well-and-truly over.

 

Just to ensure there would be no way back for the Eegs, the Satiners scored the first three goals of the third term. Koschitzke booted the first following an emphatic pack-mark of King's lobbed kick. The Wiggles hung in there for a few minutes until Jason Gram was pleased to accept Goddard's handball and thump an idiomatic running goal from 50m. A minute later Weeg man Daniel Kerr accidentally soccered on-the-full in his back-pocket and Montagna quickly chipped the free for Kerr's opponent, Clint Jones, to mark 15m out, play-on and slam it through. Jones was giving Kerr a bath as the Saints were doing to the Weegs, Sinkilda leading by 82 points now. The pressure eased and the Wiggles managed some goals, Nicoski cleverly intercepted a Riewoldt handball (bet he'd been sweating on that) and kicked long where Quinten Lynch seized a strong mark over Zac Dawson, Lynch goaled. A bit later Shannon Hurn managed a rare bouncing run and long kick, McKinley took a decent grab and majored. There were a handful of behinds before Hunter booted a goal after out-marking Sam Fisher and the Eegs had 'slashed' the margin to 54 points. But then Gwilt and Dal Santo combined to set up an easy mark and goal for Gardiner, Gardiner and Dal Santo then cleared the subsequent centre-bounce and Dal Santo soon re-appeared on the forward flank, his long punt resulting in a major for Adam Schneider. The Weegs constructed an end-to-end move from a kick-in and LeCras handballed for McKinley to snap accurately, the stanza ended with Lynch booting a 55m sausage and the Saints led by 66 points or 11 goals at the final tyrnabout. After Lynch and Hurn missed early shots in the final Mario the Eegs turned it up and set about damage control, with limited success. They were also pretty tired; it was warm day in Melbourne. The Saints coasted home with five unanswered goals, the most popular probably the last as full-back Zac Dawson booted the first goal of his career, slipping forward to mark Schneider's pass. Before then Milne had bagged a couple, one from typical roving, the other courtesy a very technical 50m penalty following a mark. Riewoldt and Hayes kicked the others. Perhaps it was disappointing they didn't crack the 100-point margin, Gram and Jones both had late chances but missed.            

 

Blonde Sainter throw-back Clint Jones (25 disposals, 6 marks, a goal) won praise for his game on Kerr and Brendon Goddard (28 touches, 12 marks, 4 goals) made a very useful forward. Leigh Montagna (31 possies, 8 marks, a goal) was great early while midfield fellow Nick Dal Santo (31 touches, 7 marks, a goal) was consistently good. The big forwards played well again, Justin Koschitzke (8 marks, 8 kicks, 4 goals) is up and going, Nick Riewoldt (26 possies, 12 marks, a goal) played much better than the first two rounds. Sam Gilbert (21 disposals, 11 marks) gave another very assured performance at CHB, with Matt 'Goose' Maguire supposedly ready to return. Michael Gardiner kicked 2 goals, fifteen Saints overall scored goals. Ruck-rover Matthew Priddis (30 disposals) was the Weegs' most consistent performer, Daniel Kerr (27 disposals) had a bit of the ball, often in the back-line and he wasn't very dangerous. Dean 'Big' Cox (24 handlings, 11 marks) and Andrew Embley (18 possies, 5 marks) were both handy, although Cox is being accused of kick-chasing. Full-back Darren Glass (10 touches, 4 marks) went alright considering. Mark LeCras booted 3 goals while there were 2 each from Adam Hunter, Ben McKinley and Quinten Lynch. Worsfold said "The result was very hurtful . . . embarrassing and disappointing. You'd hate to think (the Satins) could go any better. There's no doubt we were outplayed by a far superior side, but the extent (of the loss) is disappointing . . . they're a very good side but we were well below what's acceptable . . . There were certainly occasions when (Wiggle) players didn't go as hard at a contest as we expect them to do. They've got to put everything on the line and they've got to look their team-mates in the eye regarding that. If they can't, they should ask not to play for us." Ross Lyon is trying to keep a lid on. "It was a bit like the Adelaide performance (today). Let's whack a grain of salt in there, it's round three. Certainly we've won three games, which is pleasing, and it's easy to get carried away but we're certainly not. Last year we were two-zero and it's nice to be three-zero but it's a marathon and you can get ahead of yourself pretty quickly." He went on to praise Goddard's performance.  

 

At the Gabba:

Brisbane  4.4   10.6   12.9   15.10.100

Sydney   1.2    4.5    7.10   9.13.67

 

Whenever a streak is brought up, you can be certain it's going to be broken. The Lyin's hadn't beaten the Swans for five years or something, a period covering nine games and the fact was raised repeatedly in previews of this game. So of course, with the new coach in place, Brisbun ended the run with an emphatic win at a rain-soaked Gabba. You could add in 'with old Swans in place' too. The Bloods were as listless as they were determined last week and every loss they have is going to be accompanied by end-of-an-era type speculation. Sidderney always take time to get going in any year, so again patience is required. But this wasn't much of an effort. The Lyin' side here was missing Rhan Hooper (ankle injury) and ruckman Jamie Charman from the loss to Carlton, Charman is struggling for fitness following an injury-plagued pre-season. In came defender Jason Roe and experienced wingman Tim Notting. One change for the Swans after speculation they'd need several, Ed Barlow replacing Luke Ablett (leg injury).

 

Steady rain greeted the players and although it came-and-went through the night, the ground was slippery. Swan Jarrad McVeigh's point was the only score in the opening five minutes, the most noteworthy event being Lyin' ruckman Matthew Leuenberger injuring a knee. He returned later but we've discovered since he's got a damaged meniscus and will miss 12 weeks - tough break. Eventually the Lyin's attacked and their captain Jonathan Brown allowed Notting's pass to skid off his hands, but was clothes-lined by Swan backman Lewis Roberts-Thomson. Brown booted a goal from the resulting free. A coupla minutes later Simon Black lobbed a noice pass for Notting to mark and convert and the Lyin's led by 11 points. The Swans responded quickly as the heavens opened, Jarred Moore won the ball well, punted long and Barry Hall out-maneuvered Dan Merrett to mark, play-on and poke it through. Quite a bit of scoreless wet weather slog after that, but the Lyin's enjoyed the bulk of possession. Lyin's Bradshaw and Power missed shots before Jed Adcock collected a ball which'd squirted from a pack and found space to run to 50m and thump a long sausage. Brisbun were running, leading by 13 points. Bradshaw and Brown missed shots before the first break but Brown also booted a goal, taking a diving, sliding mark of Josh Drummond's pass and also walloping it home from 50. Signs weren't good for the Bloods as they trailed by 20 points at the first break. They opened the second term with a determined effort, Hall again bumped off Merrett to take a mark and Hall steered a great kick for a goal from the boundary-line, the pocket it's impossible to kick accurately from according to Malcolm Blight. Swan Jude Bolton tumbled a kick forward from the restart, Brisbun backman Ashley McGrath marked - but he'd pushed Siddey man Brett Meredith in the back, and Meredith booted a great long goal from the resulting free - the first of his career. The Lyin's lead was cut to 8 points, but Malceski and Barlow failed to score with opportunities and the Brians steadied. The Swans also lost veteran stopper Jared Crouch with a hamstring problem. Brown found space to lead into and took a sliding mark of Travis Johnstone's pass, Brown booted a steadying goal. Johnstone had been Crouch's man. Then the Lyin's harder work and better ball-use began to be reflected on the scoreboard. Trying desperately not to be pinged for a deliberately rushed point, or a deliberate out-of-bounds, Roberts-Thomson was simply pinged for 'bawl' and Justin 'The Shermanator' Sherman banana-ed the resulting free-kick for a sausage. Albert Proud set up a juggled mark and goal for Bradshaw, as the rain started again Bradshaw led out to mark Drummond's pass and boot another. Cheynee Stiller threw the ball out of a pack to Johnstone - no whistle - and he handballed to running Sherman who slotted another. The Lyin's had sprinted to a 37-point lead. The Swans broke the run, Hall executed a disciplined spoil from behind and gathered the ball, he handballed for Ed Barlow to snap truly. But Barlow missed a subsequent chance and the Lisbon Brians answered, the busy Drummond taking a diving with-the-flight mark of Proud's kick, playing-on quickly and thumping it home. The Brians led by a healthy 37 points at half-time.

 

The Swans made an effort in the third stanza but could never exert the coach interstate's beloved favourite, scoreboard pressure. Bradshaw booted the opening goal, benefitting from Sherman's strong lead and mark and slick handpass to Adcock, who hit leading Bradshaw with the pass. A Johnstone point made it 43 points the diff, before Sidderney's Kieran Jack lowered his eyes and hit ruckman Jesse White with a pass, White converted with a noice kick. There was a miss each before a Lyin' turnover allowed Brett 'Captain' Kirk to chip a pass to unattended Hall, he goaled and the Swans trailed by 30. Brown replied for the Brians, leading to mark Joel Patfull's well-weighted pass. The Bloods finished the term with some effort, Adam Goodes lobbed a kick towards the pocket and Darren Jolly literally shoved Jason Roe aside to mark and convert. The Brisbun folk couldn't believe Roe didn't get a free, the ump reasoning the pushing was in the side, maybe. But Jolly and Jude Bolton proceeded to miss set-shots and the Swans trailed by 29 points at the final change, still a long way given the conditions. The final term started very slowly as the Lyin's locked the game down. Swan Mattner's behind was the only score in the opening ten minutes, before Lyin' junior Daniel Rich booted a long goal, a free-kick for tackling Roberts-Thomson in the act of kicking - 'bawl'. Rich converted from outside 50, some great long-kicking in the wet here. That put the Lyin's 44 points ahead and well home. Jolly free-kicked another goal for the Swans, placed in a head-lock by Merrett while trying to take a mark. But Bradshaw replied immediately for the Lyin's, after bending to mark Black's kick by his knees. Into time-on and Sherman added icing with his third goal, soccering the pill from a throw-in. Siddey's Moore kicked a goal after the final siren.   

 

Scuttling Lyin' midfielder Jed Adcock (25 disposals, a goal) enjoyed the conditions and the Lyin's also received a good game from Josh Drummond (25 possies, 12 marks, a goal) and his raking left boot. Drummond's last two seasons were ruined by injury but he's enjoying a good run at the start of 2009. Big forwards Jonathan Brown (11 kicks, 7 marks, 4 goals) and Dan Bradshaw (7 kicks, 7 marks, 4 goals) have started the season well too as has the usually less reliable Justin 'The Shermanator' Sherman (13 possies, 3 goals). Joel Patfull (9 disposals) kept Goodes quiet while Travis Johnstone (14 kicks) did some classy things. For the Swans, in-and-under man Jude Bolton (29 disposals, 5 marks) battled away and ruckman Darren Jolly (11 disposals, 6 marks, 46 hit-outs, 2 goals) played well again. Kieran Jack (17 touches) tagged Luke Power effectively and backman Ted Richards (19 possies, 8 marks) was alright. Barry Hall booted 3 goals. Paul Roos acknowledged the Brians' superior effort. "Teams that can tackle really well and put pressure on the opposition are the teams that are going to be successful again in 09, Brisbane were really good in that area tonight," Roos said. "Hopefully our young guys learn really quickly, the five or six guys that we had. But it's still up to your senior players to set the pattern for the rest of the group and that's probably where they were better than us in that regard." Michael Voss played up the 'new era' angle, perhaps implying the Swans' was over. Or maybe I'm reading too much into his comments. "It's the best team effort we've had," said Vossy. "It's a new fresh start, new coach and new style, so it was very pleasing to see everyone gel together and do their part, and not rely on any one individual. And that was what it was going to take to beat a team like Sydney . . . They've been able to a do a job on us a number of times, but it was important to say, this is a fresh start. As far as we were concerned, I guess it was zero-all and we had to come in with that intent, to find a new way."

 

At the MCG:

Carlton   4.6   7.10   13.13   16.16.112

Essendon  1.4   8.6    15.7    17.14.116

 

An upset to be sure as the Bommers and their fired-up skipper Matty Lloyd pricked the Bluies' balloon. A great response from the Dons to a week of fairly negative press and exciting for their fans to see some of The Kids come on. A few pundits have pointed out the Blooze don't have the strongest of back-lines and they were exposed here, especially without Michael Jamison (shoulder), set for an extended absence. Bluie fans could whinge about several factors; the gee-up the press had given the Bummers; their own Brendan Fevola's bizarre inaccuracy; the umps handing the Dons one of those ridiculous double-goals during the third stanza. Such is life, as Ben Cousins's stomach says. The Blues had Nick Stevens return from a pre-season suspension and called up half-back Shaun Grigg. They replaced Jamison and dropped veteran Heath Scotland, who's had a slow start to his year. The Bommers had Jay Nash and Leroy Jetta into the side, replacing suspended Adam McPhee and last week's debutant Michael Quinn, harshly axed.

 

Huge crowd of 70,400 turned out and they saw a great game, one of a recent series between these two. It's a bit difficult to put some of these Blue/Bommer clashes into context, as certain players and the teams as a whole never to seem to match the performance before or after. The Bluesers began very well but didn't put it on the board. Brendan Fevola had Darcy Daniher as an opponent and out-marked him twice in the early minutes, but missed both times, albeit from tight angles. Simon Wiggins - arguably the worst shot for goal in the leeg - also kicked a point before the Bluies managed a goal, ruckman Matthew Kreuzer slapped a throw-in out the back and Chris Judd gathered, he was tackled while kicking but Jordan Russell scooped up the ball and wobbled a snap through with his left boot. The Dons scored a coupla behinds before Eddie Betts snapped a major for the Bluies, from a ball-up about 30m out. Carton led by 13 points. The Dons cleared the restart, Brent Stanton went long and Matty Lloyd leaped to juggle a two-grabber over Bret Thornton. Lloyd booted his first goal of the season and a "sense of relief swept the ground" according to one TV commentator - Gerard Twhately, possibly. But Juddy and the Carlton Crew continued to dominate (where's Mick Gatto?), Judd started a move from half-back and Jeff Garlett passed for leading Fevola to mark strongly in front of Daniher and punt truly this time. Judd lobbed a high kick forward from the restart and Wiggins leaped for a emphatic grab, he quickly handballed to running Marc Murphy who slotted. The Blues led by 20 points but Fevola missed again, as did Simpson. Lloyd and Jetta obliged for the Dons and Carton were still 20 points up at the first break. Into the second Mario (Condello?) and Fevola got on-target again, after maneuvering Daniher under the ball and marking 12m out, right in front. The Blues led by 27 points but the Dons began to get moving now, receiving a lift from midfielders Andrew Lovett and Jobe Watson and forward Angus Monfries. Paddy Ryder, (briefly) shifted to the ruck won the next centre-clearance, resting David Hille gathered and handballed for an Alwyn Davey six-pointer. Then Henry Slattery's tap-on and Ricky Dyson's great pass set up a running major for Courtenay Dempsey, a terrific goal. Dempsey soon bagged another, from a 50m penalty against Grigg who slightly encroached the mark, the Blueser lead was cut to 10 points. The Blues replied as a Nick Stevens pass intended for Fevola dropped short but Ryan Houlihan chipped in to mark it, Houlihan majored. The Bombouts replied rapidly as Lovett passed wide to find Stanton, who played-on and roosted a superb kick from 50m for a sausage roll. A minute later David Hille fisted a throw-in goal-wards and Watson ran onto the ball to snap it through. Dons were only 3 points down, 2 after a Lovett miss. Fevola supplied relief again for the Bluies, a hopeful high punt from Cam Cloke spilled from a big pack and Betts swept up the ball and passed to leading Fev, he majored. But Murphy was done for 'bawl' at the restart and Hille passed for leading Lloyd to hold a noice grab and boot truly. Fevola missed a shot and there was good Don move from the kick-in, Dempsey twice involved before Hayden Skipworth passed for leading Scott Lucas (remember him?) to take a mark and boot a goal. Fevola missed yet again prior to half-time, where the Bummers led by 2 points.

 

The balance of power see-sawed through a free-scoring third stanza. The Bluies scored direct from the opening bounce, Murphy punted forward and Betts did very well to retrieve the ball despite having his head sat-on (almost), Betts's handball was gathered by Wiggins who snapped truly. Another Fev behind before Lucas replied for the Dons, converting after being awarded a diving mark he appeared to trap on the half-volley. A minute later Stanton's excellent vision and kick enabled Lloyd, drifting behind Thornton, to mark and steer it through from the flank. Lloydy was still wandering up the ground a bit, but staying closer to the goals more often. Soon the Dons were advancing again, Lucas led wide to mark Winderlich's pass and then chip one ahead to Skipworth, who played-on and got into some trouble before grubbering a lucky snap for full points. The Dons led by 13 points at this stage. The 'baggers responded, some good handball found Stevens in space and he punted towards a heavily out-numbered Fevola, but Betts pounced on the pack-spillage and snapped truly off the left boot. A bit later Houlihan read Grigg's kick smartly to mark over Stanton, Houlihan goaled and the Bluesers were level. Wiggins missed a shot before Sam Jacobs climbed high at a throw-in to tap down to Houlihan, Wiggins couldn't mark Grigg's pass under pressure from Myers but Grigg, running on, swept up the pill and snapped truly. Junior Bluies Hadley, Johnson and Robinson combined to win the restart and this time Garlett roved Wiggins's contest to bag a sausage. The Blues were on a roll, leading by 13 points. But the Dons steamed home to three-korter time. David Zaharakis punted towards Lloyd, he out-marked Thornton and slotted from the pocket. Lovett won the ball at the restart, Watson kicked long and Lloyd was clattered front-on by Thornton, the Bloo man could claim he was going for the ball but it didn't look good. Lloydy free-kicked a goal and Bomma Davey decided to tell Thornton about it. Thornton knocked Davey to the ground - a light push - and the Bommers were rewarded with a free to Davey, who scored one of those infuriating double-goals. Davey was shameless enough to try and milk another, but the ump was on to his diving. Anyway, a minute later Ryder marked Lovett's pass 50m out and banged it between the big sticks, four straight goals from the Bummers and they led by 12 points. Wiggins stemmed the bleeding with a very late goal, playing-on and dobbing it after Stevens pinched the ball off Zaharakis. Still anyone's as the Dons led by 6 points at the final break. The final term opened with a handful of behinds - another from Fev - before Bomma Nash, I think, was penalized for a deliberate out-of-bounds; you know they're only paid within range of the sticks and Bloo Murphy duly majored, the Dons led by a point. The Bombouts replied immediately, Lloyd couldn't mark under pressure but Monfries roved smartly to stab a goal from a tight angle. Dons by 7. A behind each, then a quickly-taken free-kick by Kreuzer and Judd in the centre caught 'floating' Don backman Fletcher out of position and Fevola led out for an easy mark and, finally, another goal. Dons by a point again. Tight and tense for a few minutes after that, the Bommerz led by 2 points in early time-on when Wiggins fumbled a hot handpass in his back-line, the ball ended with Nash who jabbed a short pass to Stanton. The Don man goaled and Essadun led by 8 points. Jetta's miss made it 9 before the Bluies forced a turnover and Paul Bower punted long to a big pack, the unlikely rookie Blue ruckman Jacobs gathered the spillage and wobbled a goal, his first ever I believe. The Dons led by 3 points, a Hille behind made it 4. The Blues were attacking a minute later, Murphy balanced himself for a snap but Ryder's great tackle prevented it, Ryder also gathered the ball and cleared it to ensure the Dons' safety.     

 

Brent Stanton (26 disposals, 8 marks, 2 goals) was very good for the Dons, as was Andrew Lovett (21 touches, 5 marks) who seems to save his best for Carlton. The press was all over Matthew Lloyd (16 disposals, 10 marks, 5 goals) while speedy Courtenay Dempsey (21 handlings, 8 marks, 2 goals) had a bit of a breakthrough game. Another Blue specialist, Angus Monfries (20 touches, 8 marks, a goal) played well and David Hille (18 disposals, 4 marks, 21 hit-outs) turned in a smart rucking performance. Alwyn Davey bagged 2 goals as did an improved Scott Lucas (9 kicks, 8 marks). For the Blues, three of their 'big four' were very good. They'd be Chris Judd (33 disposals), Marc Murphy (20 possies, 2 goals) and Nick Stevens (23 touches, 7 marks). Bryce Gibbs was pretty decent, too. Jarrad Waite (15 touches, 6 marks) did well down back and Eddie Betts (9 touches, 2 goals) was lively as ever in attack, Simon 'Chief' Wiggins (16 touches, 11 marks, 2 goals) was a strong presence at half-forward. Brendan Fevola contributed a maddening 4.7 from 12 shots, 10 marks and 13 kicks. Ryan Houlihan (19 disposals) kicked 2 goals. Bloo coach Ratten was philosophical, while blaming Fev. "When you have that many shots on goal . . . we had a chance to put a fair gap in the game and, like most games, if you don't make the opposition pay you get burnt the other way and we did, there's no doubt about it. To Essendon's credit, they locked it in and had a real one-on-one approach and made it tough for us . . . I think it's a reminder to us and, even the competition, how even it is, and to think we've had some real positive press at our club, which is great. But . . . if you put one foot wrong you're brought back down to earth, and I think it was a good lesson for our group, and not just the players, the coaching group as well to make sure we get everything right." Matty Knights said "I think Matthew Lloyd probably summed it up best after the game when he said it's one of the prouder wins he's been involved in, particularly when you line up with Darcy at full-back and Tayte Pears at centre half-back knowing they are going to have their hands full at times against really good players. To be twenty points down at quarter-time, the resilience the players showed to stick to our game plan . . . we got ourselves back in the game around stoppages, which was a big plus, because they were causing us all sorts of problems early. It was a big game for us to win and a great experience for our younger players to be involved in such a fantastic victory." Knighta went on to give Lloydy a big wrap.  

 

At Football Park:

Port Adelaide  3.3   10.5   16.12   22.15.147

Melbourne      2.1    4.4    7.5     14.6.94

 

Ah, Port confirmed most people's thoughts by thumping a weaky, the Deez. Of course thuggery was involved, Port's captain Dom Cassisi involved in a particularly craven example which's cost him a week. Let's see how the Powermen go against the Hawks at the 'G next week. At this stage of 2008 the Demuns had almost lost their first three by over 100 points each, so they could be said to have improved. They're a chance for a win against the benighted Tigers this Sundy. Port made three changes to the side embarrassed in Perth, Justin Westhoff will be missing for quite a while with a broken foot while Toby Thurstans and David Rodan were dropped. Incoming were Dean Brogan, returning from suspension, young backman Matt Thomas and first-gamer Wade Thompson, a small forward from North Adelaide who performed well in the NAB Cup. Daniel Motlop played his 100th AFL game. The Dees lost skipper James McDonald with a hamstring problem and dropped raw ruckman Jake Spencer, in came Lynden Dunn and new man John Meesen, a ruckman who played a game or two with the Camrys three years ago. Aaron Davey was very proud to play his 100th game for the Dees.

 

Another warm sunny day and the first half was reasonably competitive until the Powder kicked clear with a barrage of goals just before half-time. The opening minutes were fairly tight until the Power were handed a goal, Dom Cassisi was pushed in-the-back at a ball-up and had a free, a 50m penalty was added when Dee Colin Sylvia dumped Josh Carr a few metres away. Sylvia was reported, but not suspended. Cassisi majored. A few minutes later Warren Tredrea fought hard to win the ball, swapped handballs with Robbie Gray and raced into the goal-mouth to snap it through. The Dees were doing a lot of defending, eventually Daniel Motlop bullocked Ricky Petterd aside to win the pill and handball to Cassisi, he found Dean Brogan with a pass and the temperamental ruckman majored. Port led by 19 points, 3.1 to nuthin'. The Dees began to win some ball through Davey and Nathan Jones. Jones's long kick into a paddock set-up enabled Neville Jetta to take a with-the-flight mark, Jetta booted a sausage. A minute later Jared Rivers bombed a kick in and Brad Green held a strong grab in front of Surjan, Green majored and the Dees trailed by 6 points, and 8 at the first break. Port continued to push hard into the second term but found it hard to crack the Dees' flooded defence, until Kane Cornes jabbed a pass for leading Tredrea to mark and convert from 50m, a great kick. But the Demuns won the next centre-clearance, James Frawley's kick slewed off the side of his boot but straight to Brent Moloney, alone on the 50m line, who played-on and drilled it. Port won the subsequent centre-break, there was a fairly ordinary pass going forward but their Travis Boak recovered the pill and chipped a kick for Kane Cornes to mark 20m out and steer it through. Port led by 14 points, the Dees managed some attacking but Jones and Matthew Bate both kicked behinds. Not exactly sure when the incidents happened but Cassisi and Peter Burgoyne were both reported during the second term, Cassisi was in the clear and gave off a handpass, then turned and went back looking for Dunn to flatten him. Stoopid, he got a week. Peter Burgoyne also gave some biff after disposing of the ball, kneeing a prostrate Davey in the back. He's been suspended two games. It stayed tight on the scoreboard, Brogan's lead and mark set up a chance for Port, Tredrea gathered the ball in the forward-pocket and his tumbly centering kick was a shocker, but bounced luckily for Chad Cornes to gather and snap through. Melbun replied with a goal from Green and the Dees were 12 points down again. But the Flowers banged through four goals in time-on to really open a gap. First up Motlop did brilliantly to intercept a Dee defender's kick and punt forward where Tredrea was alone for an easy mark and goal. Then Cassisi chipped ahead to find Brogan in a ocean of space, the Port man handballed over-the-top to fellow ruckman Brendon Lade in the goal-square, Lade poked it through. A minute later Troy Chaplin drove the ball forward, Wade Thompson roved the big men and his attempted snap sliced wide but went handily straight to Matt Thomas, who marked and converted. Then Chad Cornes kicked smartly for wide-leading Brett Ebert to mark, Ebert punted to the top o' the 'square where roving Robbie Gray snapped a major. Port had jumped to a 37-point lead at half-time.

 

The Power stretched the lead over the error-prone Dees in the third stanza, again late in the piece. Early goal in the third for Port as Tredrea led long, marked and lobbed a ridiculously high kick forward, but Lade was good enough to win it and handball for oncoming Motlop to slot it through. The Powder proceeded to miss a number of shots, amongst the behind barrage there was a goal for Tredrea after he marked Thomas's well-placed kick. A few minutes later Shaun Burgoyne jabbed a short pass to Danyle Pearce, who was smart enough to have a shot from 55m and see his kick bounce through an empty 'square for full points. The Flowers were cruising with a 59-point lead at this stage and the Dees were having real trouble going forward. But they manufactured a coupla goals at this point, Dunn snapped one from a throw-in and Jones tumbled a kick forward from the following centre-bounce, Bate did very well to win the agget and pass to Brad Miller, leading into the pocket. Miller threaded it through, slashing the margin to 47 points. Port banged through the goals in time-on, Gray led wide to accept Steven Salopek's pass and then he centered a pass to leading Tredrea who marked and converted. Gray also set up the next, sort-of, deciding to kick the ball 30m along and 100m up. Josh Carr was almost decapitated by Frawley as he tried to gather Gray's artillery shell and Carr free-kicked a major. Brogan was dragged down at the restart and handballed his free to Shaun Burgoyne, Gray marked Burgoyne's kick strongly over Cheney, played-on and slotted. The Powder led by 66 points. Cam Bruce, a hard-running Green and Petterd set up a late tap-through goal for Dee Cale Morton but it was kinda irrelevant, Port 61 points ahead at the final change. But the Demuns lifted themselves to win a high-scoring final korter, which was something. They scored three goals in the first five minutes, firstly Bate's long handpass found Bruce cantering through the 50m line and Bruce's low kick scored full points. Davey won the ball from the restart and his kick found Bate in plenty of space, the Fanta-pants booted truly from 45m. Another Dee centre-clearance followed, with John Meesen simply shoving Lade aside, and eventually Dunn passed for leading Green to mark and boot a goal. Port led by 43 points but they responded quickly, Chad Cornes maneuvering smartly in front of Rivers to mark brother Kane's kick and punt a major. Tredrea majored from a strong grab of Ebert's centering kick, Carr passed for Motlop to mark and convert and Port's ten-goal lead was restored. Goals alternated after that, Motlop snapped a lairy one after selling about four dummies and Gray battled hard to create one for Boak, on the Dee side Bate and Bruce added majors and Jamie Bennell kicked the first goal of his career, Bennell's kick also created the final goal of the game, for Miller. The Dees won the final stanza by 4 points, but lost the game by 57.    

 

Six goals from Warren Tredrea (13 disposals, 9 marks) represented his best haul in four years. Steven Salopek (33 touches, 6 marks) played very well midfield as did Peter Burgoyne (35 touches, 6 marks, a goal), pity about his temper. Travis Boak (30 handlings including 23 handballs, a goal) and Danyle Pearce (28 possies, 7 marks, a goal) joined in the midfield stat-fest while Nathan Krakouer (31 disposals) has quickly carved a spot for himself on a back flank. Chad Cornes (29 possies, 9 marks, 2 goals) motored up-and-down the ground to good effect, Daniel Motlop bagged 3 goals in his milestone game while Robbie Gray kicked 2. For the Deez Aaron Davey (30 disposals) tried very hard and Brent Moloney (18 touches, a goal) and Brad Green (17 handlings, 11 marks, 3 goals) battled away. Green is playing as a key forward in the absence of a useful alternative. Younger midfielders Nathan Jones (25 possessions), Brock McLean (21 touches, 4 marks) and Cale Morton (28 touches, 9 marks, a goal) were decent performers. Cam Bruce (29 disposals) kicked 2 goals, so did Brad Miller and Matthew Bate. "I think it's clear our young players are going to gain from the experience," began Dee coach Dean Bailey. "We fought pretty hard to win the last quarter, that's a plus for next week. The thing that I can say about our players is that they are committed to improvement, there's no question about that. Their attitude has been fantastic considering last year; our pre-season was good and our application has been first-class. I hope they get some reward for their effort. I can see it coming." Maybe next Saturday. Port man Mark Williams said "I was really happy with what (the Port players) did. The last quarter was pretty disappointing but in the end we still had nine shots on goal and kicked six goals." He waxed lyrical about Tredrea's performance, and was asked about Port's thuggery (er, reports). "The coaches don't have a role to play when it comes to reports. We just look at the sheet and see what it was for. We'll wait and see," he said. "Every club and anyone that's playing AFL footy would rather have a strong side than a weak side. The balance is always interesting."

 

At Docklands:

North Melbourne  2.1    5.5    8.9   10.9.69

Hawthorn         4.1   10.4   15.5   19.9.123

 

The Hawkers broke the ice with an impressive win over their bogey side, North. The Kanger players were allegedly subdued following 'Chickengate', a video they made of a rubber chicken, er, 'interacting' with a frozen supermarket chicken which, inadvisably, made its' way onto the web. A huge fuss was made of this, with senior players Adam Simpson and Daniel Pratt fined over it. Anyway, the Orcs got back to some great running footy over the lackluster Ruse but ran into more injury problems, Xavier Ellis suffering a foot injury in the first quarter and Grant Birchall damaging thumb ligaments. They can't take a trick. Senior man Stephen Gilham and Travis Tuck returned here at the expense of Josh Kennedy and Mitchell Thorp. The Ruse recalled Josh Smith and Corey Jones - I thought Laidley claimed to be rebuilding? - while axing Todd Goldstein and Ed Lower. 

 

The opening quarter was pretty ordinary with players seeming half-asleep on a warm, sunny Easter Sunday. The best early chance for a goal came when Hawk Brent Guerra turned and passed towards his own goal, but there was no-one there. Roo Lindsay Thomas gathered the ball but his shot sliced for a behind. Kanga Michael Firrito broke the ennui with a free-kicked goal, Sam Mitchell literally ploughing him into the ground at a throw-in. But soon Mitchell was winning a stack of possession and Jarryd Roughead got the Hawks got moving. Their first major soon arrived as Roughead scooped up Cyril Rioli's strange under-hit pass, wheeled around onto the left boot and banged it through. Again a long scoreless spell, the Hawks engaged in much chip-about before Rioli speared a much better pass for Roughead to mark strongly in front of the pack and wallop through. A minor floodgate opening in time-on, Rue Matt Campbell benefitted from the new rule against 'dumping' to win a free and 50m penalty, he goaled and Norf led by a point. Campbell missed an equally easy shot a minute later and now 'Buddy' fired, leading wide to take a great grab between opponent Josh Gibson and Scott McMahon. Franklin majored with a very noice kick. A minute later Roo Firrito was done for 'bawl' from a ball-up, probably the first legitimate tackle of Franklin's career. And it was borderline in-the-back. Anyway, Franklin converted and the Hawkers led by 12 points. The Ruse hadn't done a lot but they did exert some pressure in the early second Mario. Brent 'Boomer' Harvey tidied some scrappy play with a handpass to Brady Rawlings and from his lobbed punt Drew Petrie held a solid grab, Petrie goaled. A minute later Orc defender Thomas Murphy's wayward handball was intercepted by 'Lethal' Leigh Harding, he stabbed a major and the Kangers led by a point. But the Awks dominated the remainder of the quarter, starting from the next centre-bounce which Mitchell cleared, the ball went wide to Brendan Whitecross and he passed for everyone's favourite consumer of Easter eggs, Stuart Dew, to mark and boot truly from 50m. Franklin missed a shot but a moment later Campbell Brown's typically tenacious effort to win the ball set up a goal-square tap-through for Buddy. A few minutes later Jarryd Morton was a bit lucky when, following a good mark 55m out, he played-on and stuffed it up. Luckily Harding shoved him in the back as Morton kicked and the ump awarded a downfield free, to Dew in the goal-square. He lobbed it through. Then Roughead was awarded a free as he crashed heavily into a pack in a marking contest, probably because he was pushed into it. Roo David Hale bore the brunt of 'Roughy' and had to be stretchered off with a suspected neck injury, but Hale didn't get a free. Roughead converted and the Orcs led by 22 points. A bit later the Ruse were denied a certain goal by Guerra's great tackle on Thomas in the goal-square. It looked kinda high and/or in-the-back to me, but Thomas did take a bit of a dive. The Hawks rebounded swiftly and Chance Bateman booted a great running goal. The Ruse finally broke the run as Jack Ziebell lobbed a high punt to the top o' the 'square, Daniel Wells roved and copped Brown's shoulder to the face as he tried to baulk the Hawk. Wells free-kicked a goal and Brown was reported, although he got off, probably fairly. Wells made a lot of it. Roughead ended the term with another goal capping another super-speedy Hawk rebound, a free for having his arms chopped in the marking contest by Scott Thompson, and the Horks led by 29 points at the long break.

 

With Hale off (he's alright, playing this week apparently) Roo coach Laidley re-organised his forward-line for the third term, sending McMahon forward and Josh Smith to CHF, Petrie to the goal-square. It gave the Kangers brief hope, Petrie booted an early goal following a diving mark of Gavin Urquhart's kick. Then McMahon kicked one after a smart pass from Thomas and the Kangers loitered 17 points down. The Awks responded with the next three goals, a fairly scrappy backwards-handballing move ended with Ryan Schoenmakers's long kick and Morton took a brave back-pedalling mark on 50, he scored full points with a great punt. A minute later Franklin, on the wing, was allowed an eon to dispose of the ball when tackled by Campbell, Dew drove a long, flat kick in and Bateman roved Roughead's contest to snap one through. Bateman then turned provider with a smart pass to Mark Williams, who had space to play-on and drill a sausage. Horforn had eased out to a 35-point advantage. Norf hit back a bit but scored only a series of points before Harvey kicked to a big pack and all the jostling allowed Thomas to take an unopposed chest-mark. Thomas booted a goal but the Orcs buried 'em in time-on, another rapid down-the-guts rebound had Williams kick long and Roughead took an easy mark as Thompson slipped over, Roughead majored. Franklin wrestled the ball free from a throw-in and Mitchell snapped accurately, the Horks took a 38-point lead into the final change. Norf had exerted such poor defensive pressure and been so clearly beaten in the midfield, you couldn't see 'em coming back. And they didn't. Morton snapped the first goal of the final term, following some great finessing from Rioli to create the chance. A minute later Roughead marked in the centre, played-on and passed for leading Williams to mark strongly ahead of Harding. Willo sausaged and it was over now, the Orcs 50 points up. A few minutes ticked by before Roo Corey Jones majored from a free, clattered in a marking contest. Mighta been his first kick. Travis Tuck won the ball from the restart for the Hawks and Franklin juggled a good grab in front of Gibson, Buddy played-on and stabbed it through from point-blank. Horforn then blazed a series of behinds before Kanga Thomas and Hork Dew kicked goals in junk-time.

 

Hawk rover and skipper Sam Mitchell (37 disposals, a goal) rebounded from his poor effort last week to have a great game and runnin' defender Brent Guerra (38 touches, 5 marks) carried the ball forward time and again. Chance Bateman (29 possies, 10 marks, 2 goals) was also very good. With Buddy a little subdued, Jarryd Roughead (14 handlings, 7 marks, 5 goals) provided the forward spark and half-forward Cyril Rioli (18 possies, 4 marks) was excellent again. There was a great effort from third-game wingman Brendan Whitecross (29 disposals, 10 marks) and long-time listee Garry Moss (15 possies) was handy on Brent Harvey too. Lance Franklin finished with 4 goals, Stuart Dew bagged 3 and Jarryd Morton kicked 2 goals. Hard to spot a winner for Norf, Josh Gibson (19 touches, 6 marks) won praise for a decent but not brilliant effort on Franklin while Adam Simpson (29 touches, 8 marks) was pretty good. Brady Rawlings (35 disposals) won a lot of touches without much influence. Thought Michael Firrito (20 possies, a goal) was okay while the meedya was happy with juniors Lachy Hansen (12 touches, 8 marks) and Jack Ziebell (17 disposals). Drew Petrie and Lindsay Thomas kicked 2 goals each. Laidley refused to blame 'Chickengate', but did (indirectly) blame the poor form of blokes like Harvey and Wells. "I don't know (about the effects of Chickengate) . . . you'll have to ask the players that," said Laidley. "But there was some pretty heavy criticism, I suppose, particularly of a couple of boys (Simpson and Pratt) and it's going to take a toll . . . obviously we had World War Three break out and we were trying to put our fingers in the dyke (yes, he said that) all week. So if that had an effect, I don't know; how do you measure it?" On the game Laidley said "It was pretty putrid . . . We couldn't hit the side of a barn, some of our kicking was appalling. I thought our young defenders did a pretty good job on Franklin and Roughead but it probably comes down to work-rate. I thought they just worked much, much harder than us . . . Rawlings and Simpson, they just work their backsides off. Now, they have not been our best kicks over the journey but I tell you what . . . I'd take them every day of the week on top of people who have the talent but don't work hard." That last comment was aimed at Wells, apparently. Awk coach Al Clarkson said "The players shared the ball really well. You bring one another into the game when you do that. What was pleasing for us today was that we got good contributions from some of our young guys and, importantly, some of our better players played really well. They've been down a little bit in the first part of the season."  

 

At Subiaco:

Fremantle  3.5   3.7   7.12   11.14.80

Adelaide   1.3   6.7   9.12   15.14.104

 

Tough all over for Freo as they led by a goal early in the last quarter here, but were over-run by a wind-assisted Camry side who used the ball more smartly in the end. 'Twas hot and windy in Perth and afterwards Mark Harvey (partly) blamed the AFL's scheduling for the Dockerators' lasted loss. But I'm going to lay off Harvey for a while as last week he was the subject of a particularly personal attack from Melbourne's star pundit, smug and condescending ex-Sinkilda coach Grant Thomas. Thomas said Harvey was out of his depth, by nature an assistant coach and lacking the gravitas, leadership and general skills of a senior coach. True maybe, but I don't wanna be on the same side as Thomas. From the Camrys' perspective, this game proved they're going to be a tough side to beat this year. In selection Freo stuck with a yoof policy, selecting rookie-listed Greg Broughton of Subiaco for his AFL debut along with young Clayton Hinkley and not-so-young Daniel Gilmore. They replaced axed trio Paul Duffield, Andrew Browne and Scot Thornton. Harsh on Duffield but he did turnover a helluva lot last week. The Camrys were forced into three changes, Scott Stevens returned while forward Nick Gill and defender Brad Symes were called up to replace partner-beater Nathan Bock, subject to a club suspension, Trent Hentschel (more knee problems, sadly) and Chris Knights (fractured eye socket).

 

Windy day at Sooby and it produced a scrappy, poor-quality game. The Dockers had first use of the breeze and started well, their Ryan Crowley bagged the opening goal, lurking cheat-like in the goal-square to gather Garrick Ibbotson's wobbly snap and poke it through. A bit later Paul Hasleby (very good here) lobbed a pass for leading Matty Pavlich to mark and convert, a coupla poor behinds from Hasleby and Josh Head gave the Shockers an early 14-point lead. The Camrys opened their account thanks to a Freo error, of course, Gilmore's terrible clearing kick went straight to Bernie Vince and a coupla handballs later Brad Symes was snapping truly. But it was against the run, unfortunately Freo couldn't convert as Crowley and Hasleby again scored behinds before Chris Tarrant switched play smartly and Stephen Hill kicked for Clayton Hinkley to hold a gutsy mark, running backwards into oncoming Cow Michael Doughty. A 50m penalty and Hinkley majored. At the other end junior Camry Taylor Walker missed a coupla shots in the swirly breeze, the Dockulaters led by 13 points at the first break. Probably not enough given the amount of ball they'd had. The Cressidas' turn with the wind in the second korter and they did better, canny midfield men and cleaner disposal made the difference. Strongly-constructed teenager Patrick Dangerfield set up an early goal with a two-bounce run and pass to leading Jason Porplyzia, the Porpoise converted. A coupla minutes later Doughty completed a good move with a long punt and Richard Douglas was paid a pretty dubious, juggling pack-mark 15m out, he goaled. The Camerys cleared a ball-up on the wing, Doughty kicked long and Kurt Tippett clutched a good one-grabber, another Corolla sausage put them in front, by 4 points. Freo worked hard to close down the Camrys but couldn't run the ball from their own defence and there were no goals for quite a while, before the Cows bagged two late ones. Nick Gill punted them forward, the pill spilled from Scott Stevens's spoil, Walker gathered and displayed great finesse to weave through traffic, sell a dummy and dob a great goal. A minute later Walker held a with-the-flight mark on the attacking wing and launched a long wind-assisted punt, Stevens marked a split-second before being kneed meatily in the face by oncoming Dokka McPharlin. Stevens had to be stretchered off and Gill took his kick, booting a goal. The Coronas led by 18 points at half-time.

 

Adderlayed's defensive set-up and canny running served 'em well in the third stanza too. Freo had the wind again and pressed forward early, but found scoring difficult. There were a coupla behinds before Hill snapped a noice goal, following a battling effort from several Dockers to win possession and Mundy's handpass to Hill. But in the next five minutes they only managed a couple more points, as did the Cows. Antoni Grover's kick-in from the second of those went straight to Camry Andrew McLeod, who assessed options for quite a while before passing wide to Porplyzia. He marked and majored with a great kick from the flank. A minute later a good Corolla handballing combination sent Tyson Edwards running inside 50 with a bounce and Edwards drilled a sausage, sending the Cows 22 points clear. The Shockers scored the much-needed next goal after Dean Solomon took a gutsy mark on 50 - he was 'tunnelled' - and dished off to David Mundy, who thumped it home on the breeze. But the Camrys continued to do more attacking, scoring a few more points before a passing move ended with Doughty kicking for Nathan Van Berlo to mark on the flank, VB played-on and hooked it between the big posts. The Priuses led by 25 points now and Freo hadda do something. They did, scoring two late goals. The ball spilled loosely from a weak throw-in and Hasleby sharked a Camry handpass to snap a major. A minute later Michael Johnson intercepted a clearing Camry kick and passed towards leading Tarrant, except Byron Schammer nipped in ahead of Taz to mark and boot a goal. The Dokkers trailed by 12 points at the final change and put some pressure on with three quick into-the-wind goals to start the final Georgeco Stanza. Hill's speedy run and long kick found Pavlich one-out against Andy Otten, Pav wrestled off the Camry man to gather the ball and snap truly. A minute later a dithering Walker was run down by Crowley, the ball went to Nick Suban and he chipped a pass to Tarrant, who goaled and thus leveled the scores. A bit later Head's clearing kick found Solomon in anuge amount of space, Solly floated a pass for Crowley to mark 30m out and would you Adam-and-Eve it, Crowley kicked straight. The Dockerators led by 6 points, having scored the previous five goals of the game. But they couldn't finish it. The Camrys manufactured a handballing rebound, it appeared to have come unstuck when Gill's no-look handball put McLeod under pressure but the Camry veteran had a quick left-foot shot from 55m which bounced and rolled through an empty 'square for a goal. Soon some good work from Gill allowed Scott Thompson to punt deep into the Camrys' forward-line, Tippett should've been penalized when he crashed two Dockers without getting near the ball, but he wasn't and Douglas's kick was marked in the goal-mouth by Walker, who poked it through and put the Camrys a goal ahead again. Gill soon departed with hamstring trouble but young Walker had a purple patch as he led out to mark Dangerfield's pass, then produced a very good one himself to find Porplyzia marking between two Dockers. Porplyzia majored, then it was Walker again as Camry ruckman Ivan Maric won the following centre-clearance, Simon Goodwin kicked long and Walker marked over Johnson, he goaled. Addleaid led by 18 points. Just before time-on the Dokkers received a bit of hope, Pavlich bagged a goal after roving a big marking contest he declined to join. But the Camrys advanced swiftly from a later kick-in and Thompson marked 60m out, he handballed off to running Dangerfield who bounced his way inside 50 and slotted. That was about it, the Cows leading by 18 points again. Dangerfield missed a shot before Porplyzia scored the game's final goal, lobbing an under-pressure snap through from a throw-in.   

 

The kids were the talk of this game, although it took some experienced Camrys hands in Scott Thompson (22 disposals, 5 marks) and wingman Michael Doughty (21 handlings, 7 marks) to steady the tiller. Nevertheless forward Taylor Walker (8 marks, 12 disposals, 3 goals) and hard-running midfielder Patrick Dangerfield (20 touches, a goal) were very impressive. Jason Porplyzia (12 possies, 5 marks, 4 goals) has the priceless ability kick goals when needed, Brent Reilly (22 possessions, 5 marks) went well in midfield and later as a defender on Tarrant, while Simon Goodwin (20 touches) orchestrated the defensive half. Ben Rutten (16 disposals, 7 marks) did a strong job at full-back, although wind is often a key defender's best friend. For the Freo men Paul Hasleby (28 disposals, 7 marks, a goal) showed his best form yet and ruck-rover Garrick Ibbotson (22 handlings, 8 marks) played well, Matthew Pavlich (13 kicks, 5 marks, 3 goals) battled in attack. Junior midfielder Stephen Hill (15 possessions, a goal) did a bit, gratifyingly for Freo fans after the overlooked Daniel Rich's flying start for Brisbun. Rich is a more mature body-type than Hill, though. Michael Johnson (26 touches, 9 marks) played well and rover Rhys Palmer (20 touches) was busy. Ryan Crowley kicked 2 goals. Mark Harvey knows the problem(s). "Our young side got a bit of a run-on in the last quarter. We gave ourselves a little glimmer of hope . . . then it was taken away from us quite quickly," Harvey said. "We couldn't stay composed in our decision-making, either when we were going inside the forward 50 or just in general play. (And) we mucked around with the ball too much, particularly into the breeze in the second quarter . . . When we've got the ball, we're not doing enough. We're not hurting the opposition when we should be, and then when we do turn the ball over, we're getting punished quickly. Ibbotson, Hill, Suban, Hinkley - we need them to take the game on and start to create momentum for us. They need to have confidence in things like ball movement to be able to do that." Neil Craig was happy. "Fremantle kicked five in a row either side of three quarter-time, but for our guys to end up winning by four goals was pleasing, particularly with what we had to deal with during the week with the Nathan Bock situation." He went on to talk about Bock's situation and whether he would play again the following week - he is. "I also really enjoyed the calmness of some of our younger players," continued Craig. "Dangerfield showed some real composure, Taylor Walker did with some of the things he did, but he has to tidy up his 50m penalties because that is a huge penalty in our game, and the other thing I enjoyed was how our defence worked after losing Stevens. They had to play small, but Reilly on Tarrant and the other match-ups were exceptional. Stevens was a huge loss for us after we lost Bock for the right reasons. That put us under huge strain with the positions Scott can play."

 

At Docklands:

Footscray  0.6   6.11   10.13   16.14.110

Richmond   3.4   4.8     7.10    8.15.63

 

Another Richmond-bashing opportunity for the pastimes' many enthusiasts was afforded by the Tiges' latest error-filled performance. Amongst the torrent of talkback radio abuse, scathing 'analysis' from meedya pundits and speculation as to exactly when Kevin Sheedy will replace Terry Wallace as coach (gawd), some actual useful comment came from Bulldog coach Rodney Eade. "We were second to the ball in the first quarter but then we increased our pressure and they seemed to turn the ball over." 'Rocket' could've added the Tiges' confidence dropped like meat-containing dishes on Kevin Rudd's airline dinner tray as the Bulldogs pulled away to an impressive win. The Dogs were professionalism personified and have earned three good wins as they face a tough month. In selection here the Bullies made a late change, defender Stephen Tiller replacing Jarrod Harbrow. The Tiges brought in Richard Tambling at the expense of last week's debutant Robin Nahas.

 

The Tiges were good early, boring in hard to win the contested ball and exerting much midfield tackling pressure. They didn't score enough, though. Richmun had an early goal as Dean Polo gathered Bully Daniel Cross's wayward forward punt and sent the ball wide to Joel Bowden, he passed for leading Jack Riewoldt to mark and convert. There followed a succession of behinds over the following ten minutes as both sides flooded back heavily. The Bulldogs' misses were more due to being forced into shots from distance and out wide than poor accuracy. The Tiges scored a second goal eventually, managing a quick switch and Jake King kicked long for Matt White to hold a with-the-flight grab, keep running and spear it through. The Tiges led by 12 points at this stage. More behinds including the first poor miss, from Tigger Troy 'Snake' Simmonds. Into time-on and Bully Matthew Boyd's poor clearing kick was picked off by Tige skipper Chris Newman, he handballed inboard for running Nathan 'Axel' Foley to dob a sausage. A couple more points including a poor snapped effort from Bulldog Josh Hill left the Tiges 16 points up at quarter-time. The momentum swung after the break as the Dogs lifted their work-rate and pushed right up on the Tiger defenders, who subsequently panicked when they couldn't clear the back-half and either made poor disposal choices or simply turned over possession. Bulldawg Jason Akermanis scored their seventh point before a goal arrived, ruckman Ben Hudson took a strong pack-grab from the kick-in, the ball went inboard to Dylan Addison. His shot fell short but was marked on the point-line by Josh Hill, he passed infield for Daniel 'Guido' Giansiracusa to snap it through. A minute later Tige Jay Schulz's panicky clearing kick went straight to Hill, he handballed to Lindsay Gilbee who placed his kick smartly for Shaun Higgins to mark in front of the pack, Higgins goaled. The Bullies trailed by 4 points and there was a series of behinds as the ball became clogged in congested forward-lines, although Tige Luke McGuane missed appallingly following a great pack-mark and Akermanis raced into an open goal only to hack his kick into the post. Finally Higgins set up the next goal with a smart cross-field punt to find Dale Morris marking behind the pack, he converted. It proved the prelude to a flurry of Puppy sausages (mmmm, puppy sausages). Brad Johnson was spoiled as he led to a pass but good recovery work from Akermanis and Dylan Addison allowed Johnson to banana-snap a running major. Callan Ward punted the Bulldogs into attack from the following centre-bounce and Higgins was awarded a dubious free for arm-chopping against King, Higgins booted a major. Higgins, going pretty well, then collected Gilbee's wobbly pass and lobbed a centering kick for Will Minson to take a big grab over Bowden, Minson popped it through and the Bullies had jumped to a 20-point lead. The Tiges had spent most of the quarter trapped in their own half but finally managed a break-out thanks to Brett Deledio's hard running, Deledio's kick found Schulz in plenty of space and he in turn punted forward for speeding White to mark, play-on and slam it through. The Bulldogs led by 15 points at half-time but had out-scored the Tiges 6.5 to 1.4 for the term, a fair indicator.

 

The third term opened cagily with the ball again stuck in the back halves. The Tiges had a chance when Akermanis dropped an easy mark in the Dogs' attack, the sun probably a factor. The Toigs rebounded and White passed for leading Nathan Brown to mark and convert, the Dogs' lead was back to 9 points. But their strong pressure enabled rapid responses, a floating Tigger clearing kick towards Matthew Richardson enabled Hill to spoil, Gilbee gathered and kicked long to a big pack; Brad Johnson roved smartly and snapped truly. A minute later a risky cross-goal pass from Tige Jake The Turnover King set up the hapless Richo once more, Hill again spoiled and Mitch Hahn collected the pill to dob a major. The Pups led by 22 points. The Toigs won the following centre-clearance and Brown did well to create a chance for himself, which he missed. There were a few slogging minutes, twice the Bullies kicked out on-the-full in their own back-line but the Tiges didn't punish 'em. Richmun's Mitch Morton postered with a free-kick from 15m out, at the other end Cross missed poorly on-the-run. A bit later Tigger Richard Tambling's first kick of the afternoon, greeted by Bronx cheering, was to a fifty/fifty which Bulldog Ryan Griffen won. The Bullies whipped the ball forward with handball until Giansiracusa kicked for Akermanis to mark and punt truly. The Tiges soon obliged again, ruckman Angus Graham's kick from the back-pocket was half-smothered and some fairly scrappy play followed before Giansiracusa snapped a major. Footyscray led by 33 points and seemed home, but the Big Pu55ies injected some interest with two late goals. Wingman White was tripped and jabbed his free-kick to Shane Tuck, who booted a tremendous long goal. White was also involved in the next, his smart pickup and handpass allowed Riewoldt to helicopter a low punt forward, Morton marked strongly in front of Bulldog Brian Lake and hooked it through. The Tiges were there-abouts, 21 points down at the final change. But the Bulldawgs sealed it with three quick Akermanis goals to open the final term. Ruckman Minson was handy too, he tapped an early ball-up to Higgins, he handballed while tackled to Griffen, another to Akermanis allowed the veteran to race right in and slam it through. Minson thumped the following centre-bounce forward, Tige Hislop's panicky soccer-kick went to Hill who passed for leading Akermanis to mark and convert. Richmen's Deledio raced clear of the restart and kicked long, his punt bounced and headed for goals but chasing Dog Tom Williams slapped it through - a clear, deliberately rushed behind but no free was forthcoming. They'll never pay one. From the kick-in the Dogs advanced, Addison had a coupla bounces and punted forward where Akermanis held a very good diving, with-the-flight mark. Addison's kick was probably meant for leading Johnson but Akermanis duly converted again, giving the Doggies a decisive 39-point advantage. Richardson sliced on-the-full after a strong grab between three Dogs, soon Addison's spoil on Bowden turned into a mark and he handballed for Gilbee to wallop it through from 50m. The Dogs led by 44 points. Richardson managed to boot a major after good lead-up work from Kel Moore and Deledio, but the Dogs cleared the restart and Josh Hill executed a superb one-handed, full-pace pick-up of the Sherrin and slotted a great goal. Hill also brought about the game's final major, smothering Newman's kick and getting a handpass away, running Adam Cooney banged it home from 50m. Easy as you like for the Pups.  

 

Lots of good efforts from the Pups, Lindsay Gilbee (28 disposals, a goal) was allowed a stack of possession and half-forward Shaun Higgins (24 touches, 2 goals) played very well, Jason Akermanis (23 touches, 8 marks, 4 goals) sealed it with those three goals early in the last quarter and Daniel Cross (27 possessions) was a busy rover. Brian Lake (17 handlings, 9 marks) and Josh Hill (17 possies, 8 marks, a goal) combined to combat Richardson, while Liam Picken (13 disposals) tagged Deledio effectively, even to the extent of biffing him - reported, but not suspended. Dylan Addison (19 handlings, 6 marks) did some good things. Handy Daniel 'Guido' Giansiracusa (17 touches) and Brad Johnson kicked 2 goals each. Few stand-outs for the Tigers, Nathan 'Axel' Foley (29 disposals, 7 marks, a goal) and Matt White (17 touches, 2 goals) were probably their best, Chris Newman (20 disposals, 8 marks) was alright and Shane Tuck (33 possessions, 9 marks, a goal) tried hard. Luke McGuane (21 disposals, 12 marks) battled away in defence, on Johnson I think. Matthew Richardson's overall stats were impressive (22 disposals, 12 marks, a goal) but he didn't do much damage. To the Bulldogs, anyway. 'Plough' Wallace reckoned the Tiges had met expectations to date. "We came into the season and we all got the draw four months ago, and you all know where it sits. If I went around the room, I reckon there'd be less than half of you who picked us in one game out of three so far," he said. "Probably most of you would've thought that we'd be in this situation - certainly some of you would've picked us in round one, but I don't think many have picked us in round two or three. We've played two of the top three undefeated sides, and we're not at that level. We weren't at that level last year. That's the reality of where it's at. Clearly, we need to do the next few weeks right. We know that and we understand that's the . . . situation, and we're not running and hiding." The battalion of Tiger-haters would always find you. Rocket said "The (Bulldog) side's grown in belief a lot. Any situation thrown at them, they will be able to cope with. We don't rely on Cooney, who didn't play well today, and we don't rely on Johnson. We can share the load, and I think that's a pleasing thing," Eade said. "I think we've got belief in that they are able to fight back in any circumstance and guts a win out, which is good." He went on to give a wrap to Picken and Hill, the latter of whom "had to be ridden harder than a few others." Rocket's the man to do it.  

 

Ladder after Round 3

                Pts.       %    Next Week

St. Kilda        12    172.7    Fremantle (Docklands, Sat. night)

Footscray        12    156.3    West Coast (Subiaco, Sunday)

Geelong          12    119.4    Adelaide (Football Park, Sat. night)

Carlton           8    134.6    Sydney (SCG, Saturday)

Port Adelaide     8    117.1    Hawthorn (MCG, Saturday)

Brisbane          8    108.5    Collingwood (Gabba, Fri. night)

Essendon          8    100.3    North Melbourne (Docklands, Sunday)

Adelaide          8     98.5    Geelong (Football Park, Sat. night)

------------------------------------------------

Collingwood       4    108.0    Brisbane (Gabba, Fri. night)

Hawthorn          4    102.5    Port Adelaide (MCG, Saturday)

Sydney            4     96.5    Carlton (SCG, Saturday)

North Melbourne   4     87.0    Essendon (Docklands, Sunday)

West Coast        4     83.1    Footscray (Subiaco, Sunday)

Fremantle         0     66.2    St. Kilda (Docklands, Sat. night)

Melbourne         0     60.6    Richmond (MCG, Sunday)

Richmond          0     58.9    Melbourne (MCG, Sunday)

 

Cheers, Tim.

 

 

The AFL Review is sent via an automatic email list. To join or leave the list is easy.

Please visit our website at http://www.footy.com.au/fts/newsletters.htm

OR
If you have difficulty with the above please email lists@footy.com.au
 

 

No comments: