AFL Semi Finals
How did both codes of rugby and the soccer manage to get their games live-to-air on Sydney TV on Satdy night, but the footy was on a 2-hour delay? Channel Ten decided we had to see the kids' movie 'Madeleine' for the seventeenth time. Channel Seven were scarcely better, the Swans' game on Friday night wasn't live either. Why on earth not? The All-Australian team is announced tonight, ten Geelong players have been nominated so it'll be pretty similar to last year, you'd think. I messed up Nathan Bassett's final stats last week, he played 210 games for the Camrys (none for the
At the MCG:
Footscray 2.3 6.5 11.9 16.10.106
Recent history repeated as the Dogs beat the Swarns for the third time this season, Footyscray bouncing back from their mauling against the Hawks. The Dogs were tough enough, ran enough and outplayed a tired-looking Siddey mob. This is about where the Swans were anticipated to end up, there was a period mid-season when they were seen as a genuine contender but they struggled later in the season with injuries and moderate form. And they cannot beat Collywood. The question asked continually regarding the Bloods these days is their age and the need to rebuild. It's happening already with blokes like Jarred Moore, Kieran Jack and Craig Bird coming through this year but looking at some of those running 'round, there are some problems. How Jared Crouch gets a game is a mystery, Leo Barry should think about it and if Tadhg Kennelly really wants to go back to
A fairly open, end-to-end start to the game, thought to favour the Bullies. Both sides had numbers back though and there was some poor early shooting. An accurate Ben Hudson snap for the Dogs was touched off-the-boot, then Adam Goodes, Ryan O'Keefe and Psycho-Barry Hall all missed for the Bloods, Hall's a very difficult banana-shot from a tight angle. The Doggies had
The Puppies kicked away in the third term, out-numbering the Bloods at contests and just about everywhere else, it seemed. The Swans appeared a tired outfit. Early in the stanza Hargrave roved a contest on the wing and his centering kick found Stephen Tiller in plenty of space, Tiller kicked into the pocket where Josh Hill was awarded a two-grab mark against big Spida, who claimed the first touch was all his. Spida had a case, but Hill booted a good goal from a tricky angle. Hill had another chance a moment later, a free kick for being held by Malceski, but Hill missed awfully. Bully Adam Cooney dropped an easy mark when leading and then wasn't awarded a marginal grab in the goal-square, Higgins free-kicked a point after being clattered off-the-ball by Barry. The Dogs were pressing, the floodgates straining and they finally opened. Cooney's over-head handball found running Callan, he punted long and Hill arrived to seize a good grab, he converted to have the Doggies 19 points ahead. At the other end Mattner snapped a behind from a ball-up, Siddey's first score of the korter and a poor miss in context, Mattner had time to steady. The kick-in led to a throw-in which Hill cleared with some class and skill, his kick was swept up in the centre by Lindsay Gilbee who handballed to running
Very even team effort from the Bulldogs. Ruck-rover Matthew Boyd (33 disposals, 7 marks) lifted from last week to be an important ball-winner, similarly running men Lindsay Gilbee (28 touches, 9 marks) and Ryan Griffen (20 handlings, a goal) were much bigger factors than against the Awks. Down back Dale Morris (15 possies, 8 marks) kept Goodes very quiet and Ryan Hargrave did well on O'Keefe, Tim Callan (12 possies) did some useful things. Daniel Giansiracusa (18 disposals, 7 marks) was a handy half-forward and Mitch Hahn (14 possies, a goal) used his strength again, forwards Robert Murphy (16 possies, 11 marks, 3 goals) and Josh Hill (9 touches, 3 marks, 2 goals) were important. Noice game from ruckman Ben Hudson, too. Scott Welsh and Nathan Eagleton kicked 2 goals each. No stand-out for the Swans, Brett Kirk (22 disposals) battled hard and kept Cross pretty quiet, Barry Hall (16 touches, 10 marks, 4 goals) had the better of Lake in the end and Amon Buchanan (19 touches) wasn't bad. Jarrad McVeigh (20 disposals, 6 marks) has had a good year, pity about that missed shot, and Marty Mattner (19 handlings) was alright. Craig Bolton (17 possies, 5 marks) did his usual job on Brad Johnson. Paul Roos reckoned he was happy with the year overall. "We had our chances (tonight)," he said. "Coming off last week with a bit of momentum, against a team you knew was going to bounce back, you've got to take your chances and we probably didn't. Their belief started to grow and grow and they're a very good team. You don't finish third on the ladder if you can't play . . . I think we've improved on last year which is something we tried to do in then off-season and address some of things that we knew we weren't quiet as good at last year. I think we have improved as a team. Midfield talent, with the way the game is played now, is probably a little bit more important than your forward talent. That's probably an area we still need to look at." Is it rebuilding time, Roosy? "I'm not sure - possibly. It's something we need to assess in the off-season because it's hard to do it straight after the game. I think what you've got to be careful of is going down (the ladder) just for the sake of going down. As a club we have to make sure we make smart decisions and I think we've done that reasonably well [in the past]. It may be a rebuilding year but we'll see what happens in the next month." Bulldog man 'Rocket' Eade said "Obviously we didn't play very well last week and it was very disappointing, and people were circling and even some of our supporters jumped off a bit, which was also disappointing. I think they showed character with the way they played and being able to not let last week's result engulf them, and with a lack of finals experience, to be able to do what they did and bounce back like they did. We proved tonight that we should be at least in the top four. I think the players didn't want to let that slip . . . We just thought with the bigger ground, with our run . . . (the Swans) had a tough game last week, we were up there watching it and it was a tough and physical game. We thought if we could slog it with them for a half, we would probably be able to run over the top of them. That was our focus." Cats next week? "Anything can happen in a two-horse race. You can't beat them if you're not there," Eade said. "We'll go in with, and rightfully so, no one picking us, and that's fine because they're a great team. But anything can happen and there will be no pressure on us from that aspect. We've just got to play our way and back ourselves."
At the MCG:
St. Kilda 4.1 8.1 14.2 17.4.106
Collingwood 3.4 4.11 5.16 9.18.72
The value of the double chance was shown again as the Saints climbed up off the mat and cruised to victory over the Magpoise. Strange journey for the Stainers, written off by many after a very weak loss against the Poise in the wake of the 'Porky Pies' incident, they improved a bit, enjoyed a healthy slice of luck to finish fourth and are now in a prelim final against the Hawks, whom they beat the last time out. Opinions are divided regarding the Maggies' year. One argument says they and coach Mick Malthouse have done very well, given the players absent here and through the season; Heath Shaw, Alan Didak, Ben Johnson, Scott Burns, Anthony Rocca, Sean Rusling. When Shaw, Didak and Johnson were suspended following the Porky Pie thingy, most assumed Collywood wouldn't even make the eight. On the other hand, a 12-10 record in the home-and-aways is average and suggests they've a way to go to become a contender, despite being the Cats' apparent nemesis. It'd be good for the Poise if they could actually land the oft-touted big-name signing; a rumour circulated a week or so ago reckoning Jonathan Brown was 'signed and sealed' turned out to be nonsense. In selection here the Sainters made two changes to the side dismantled by
The stats tell a tale of this game. Collywood had more inside 50s and, as you can see, scored a lot of behinds. This came from the fact none of the Maggie forwards could take a mark, not helped by some awful delivery to them, resulting in a lot of hurried, roving snaps or rushed behinds by spoiling Saint backmen. And a massive number of Sainter marks in their backline. At the other end Nick Riewoldt played a towering game for the Stainers, a big part in their amazing goal-kicking accuracy. Sinkilda also won the tackle-count, a facet in which Collywood are very rarely beaten. Maligned Ross Lyon also made a coupla very good match-ups, Clint Jones tagging 'Neon' Leon Davis and Sam Fisher on Paul Medhurst. On the other hand Mick Malthouse produced a poor non-match-up, allowing form-lite Nick Dal Santo to run free. Despite all that, the first half was pretty close, as the Pies still won a lot of the ball. As would happen the Maggies opened with two behinds rushed by spoiling Saint defenders. Big Saint Justin Koschitzke didn't begin well with a clanger and a dropped mark but he soon atoned with a goal, after taking a diving mark of Robert Harvey's pass. Medhurst had a free-kick shot after being manhandled by Fisher, it drifted 'cross the face where Nick Maxwell took a good grab, but he banana-ed it on-the-full. Dale Thomas missed with a long pop before the Poise got on the board, Shannon Cox drove a long kick in and three Sinkilda backmen rose to spoil Tarkyn Lockyer. But one of 'em, Raphael Clarke, gave Lockyer a bit of a shove and the ump awarded Lockyer a free, he converted. The Pies led by 3 points, Sinkilda responded quickly as Cox was palpably caught by Jason Gram, who handballed his resulting free-kick to
Into the second and the Pies looked alright to start with, Anthony ran down Sam Gilbert but the usually accurate big man missed with the resulting free. As the Saints moved up the ground on a rebound Poi Tyson Goldsack smartly smothered a Sainter handpass, gathered and booted a clever goal to have the Pies 4 points ahead. A bit later Koschitzke managed to get himself reported, slinging Wakelin to the ground in a tackle after the Pie man had got rid of the ball. 'Kosi' has carry-over points which could have him in trouble. It was tight for a while, the Saints played some keepings-off and the Pies delivered the ball terribly inside attacking 50, bombs from O'Bree and Davis were marked by Gilbert and Goddard respectively, then Medhurst chipped a kick neatly to Jason Blake. The Saints got going again as leading Riewoldt marked strongly in front of Brown and handballed off to Gram, his hurried snap curled through for a major. A set-shot miss from Pie Anthony leveled the scores, then a series of chipped Sainter passes from Jason Blake to Dal Santo, to Lenny Hayes, to Harvey, then to leading Milne, then finally James Gwilt saw Gwilt's shot from 50m just drop through for full points. Anthony booted another long behind for Collywood. Pie backman Brown had a rare win against Riewoldt as the Sainter man pushed him in the back, Brown passed his free-kick to Rhyce Shaw but as the Poise ran it out junior John McCarthy dropped Shaw's handpass. Trying to tidy up, Shaw was tackled by Schneider and the ball spilled to Stephen Milne, who snapped a goal. O'Bree punted the Pies into attack from the next centre-bounce but Raphael Clarke marked easily for the Saints, the limitations of Anthony and Dawes as key forwards were being exposed. Travis Cloke had done nothing, it'd been rumoured he was suffering glandular fever which the Pies had denied, but Cloke did have an illness of some kind. Late in the term Goddard drove a long kick in, Riewoldt got big fly over O'Brien and Milne but couldn't hold the grab, handily Milne was like lightening in pouncing on the spillage and snapping truly. The Saints led by 14 points at half-time.
Early in the third Cloke led up to take a mark on the wing, producing much
Big game from Nick Riewoldt (20 disposals, 15 marks, 5 goals), the Saint you've got to stop - I think folks knew that already. Nick Dal Santo (32 touches, 8 marks, a goal) played his best game in an age, not given respect by Malthouse or the Poise. Robert Harvey (22 possessions) was good early and avoided his final game yet again, Jason Gram (22 disposals, 2 goals) and Leigh Montagna (29 handlings, 10 marks) were handy too. Down back Sam Fisher (27 touches, 17 marks) did the job on Medhurst and Jason Blake (27 handlings, 18 marks) kept Cloke very quiet, although Cloke wasn't a hundred percent. James Gwilt (14 touches, a goal) and Raphael Clarke (25 disposals, 13 marks) were good and Justin Koschitzke (17 disposals, 10 marks, 3 goals) had a big second half - a huge tribunal coming up. Stephen Milne bagged 3 goals. For the Poise battling Dane Swan (23 possessions, 6 marks, a goal) was best, but you'd struggle to find a clear winner. Josh Fraser (20 disposals, 8 marks, 16 hit-outs) played well 'round the ground and Scott Pendlebury (23 touches) had good stats, but minimal influence. Rhyce Shaw (21 disposals) and rover Shane O'Bree (21 touches) were okay, backman Harry O'Brien (16 possies) went in hard as usual. The Maggies had nine goal-kickers. Malthouse blamed 'tiredness' but looked ahead positively. "It's been a long year for a lot of those players - I just sensed, even at quarter time, that we had opportunities to be a better score than what we did, but I just sensed that almost every element of our indicators were down. We just didn't seem to have that energy, and it's been a pretty arduous last month or so - we've been on the road three of the last five weeks. It does catch up with you, I think anyway, probably in the second week, if you've been away a few times . . . It's no excuse, I think it's a reasonable reason that a lot of the players - particularly younger players - just lacked some of the things they gave us over the last month. So I can hardly be critical of young players, and I thought three or four of our senior players just never got near their best." He went on to stonewall a reporter who demanded to know what Mick said to the players post-game, and to berate the Pie supporters who Bronx-cheered Clokey ("I sometimes get very upset with the Bronx cheers for a bloke who was our best-and-fairest winner last year, Travis Cloke. Travis really was quite ill after last week's game."). Ross Lyon savoured a good night. "There was a couple of times where they (Collingwood) had it and they looked to go [forward] and someone got a fingernail in and we were able to turn it over. The pressure skills were good. It was important, as it would have been for the Bulldogs, that we didn't go out in straight sets. The heat would have been on the club. So it was pleasing for a lot of people who worked hard that we go a little bit deeper into the finals series. We're under no illusions about what we've got ahead of us next week, but I don't really want to talk about Hawthorn tonight and I don't want to talk about 'Buddy' [Lance Franklin]. Let me enjoy tonight and I'll go and review and get it done quickly and move on." Looks the closer of the two prelims, but the Hawks will still be warm favourites.
Next week, Preliminary Finals:
Hawthorn v St. Kilda, MCG, Sat. night.
Cheers, Tim.
The AFL Review is sent via an automatic email list. To join or leave the list is easy.
Please visit our website at http://www.footy.com.au/fts/newsletters.htm
OR
If you have difficulty with the above please email lists@footy.com.au
No comments:
Post a Comment