Collingwood Fixture 2008
Thursday, June 11, 2009
[AFL-Preview] Round 12
Last week 7 / 8 = 66 / 88 = 75%
G'day tipsters. Another dangerous tip with Essendon last week cost us the 8 from 8 but that was a game that was not decided until the 10 minute mark of the last quarter. While the experts and the detractors of the kicking style and goalfront accuracy of forwards were going to town in the past few weeks we witnessed the Bombers and the Crows put on an exhibition of amazing goal kicking to register 10 points and about 39 goals in 4 quarters of football! It was only late in the 3rd quarter that the Crows actually kicked a behind in their score of 21.4!
I don't know whether I have any readers in sunny Queensland but I am here at the Glenmore hotel in Rockhampton, deeeep in enemy territory, where workplace walls are plastered with State of Origin Rugby posters and the newspapers are full of what I consider useless information about teams called Seagulls and Rabbitohs and Tigers and Panthers and Sharks and Roosters and Cowboys and Storm et al. Uuggh!! Somebody actually tried to get me into a conversation about the game (and I use the term loosely) before I could steer the discussion to the AFL and include at least the Brisbane Lions, a team of common but relatively low interest. Readers, it has become obvious just why these places are so far behind us AFL aligned states. Hopefully the AFL can make some serious inroads into these backwaters of Australian sport and bring some light into their otherwise dull lives.
On a positive side I have noticed that hotels and pubs and clubs in QLD have these machines called pokies and while I am not a great supporter of gambling (outside tipping competitions of course) I must confess to pushing some spare currency through the slot to play a game or two while I waited for a meal. This largesse on my part cost me about $55 up to tonight when during a session while I waited for my grain fed rib eye steak there was a cacophony of sound and flashing lights and unintelligible music at the end of which the money indicator at the top left of my screen showed I had $300 credit. I immediately pushed the "collect" button hoping that this small amount would deprive the local rugby team of much needed funds resulting in them folding for the next season hence doing my bit to promote AFL. I am writing this preview sitting about 6 cms higher in the chair as my wallet is in my back pocket!!!
This week is the split round and rules often state that you must submit all your tips this week and as a result I must provide you with the preview for the two weeks. However, I reserve the right to change my educated guesses for the second week should there be a major change in team selections or coaches are sacked or another Ben Cousins saga hits the newsstands or a couple of teams decide to amalgamate or the Footy Show goes off the air.
For round 12 my nightmare is that Carlton beats St Kilda and Collingwood loses to the Swans. However, should Collingwood win and Carlton lose then, dear tipsters, The Pies will be sitting 4th on the ladder, a position they deserve.
The preview last week had me eating crow when the Bombers faded but that preview also had me regurgitating a fur ball when the Cats merely pawed at the Eagles after I had predicted a thrashing. West Coast played okay but one can only wonder just how hard the Cats were going!
Round 12 has some interesting matches so let's improve on the last two weeks and shoot for 8. Good luck.
Carlton V St Kilda at Telstra Dome Friday night
The Blues staggered over the line last week in a vital game against the Lions at the Gabba but are they good enough to topple the unbeatable Saints this week? Personally I think they will go close but at this stage of the tipping, until the Saints actually get beaten, it will be a brave tipster who can pencil in a Carlton win. I was about to provide the statistic that the Saints had not lost at Telstra this season but in fact they have not lost anywhere this season. I know and you know they will lose a game or two but I will be disappointed if it's Carlton that does it.
St Kilda by 22
Western Bulldogs V Port Adelaide in Darwin on Saturday night
The Port Adelaide versus Fremantle game last week was not a showpiece of AFL footy skills so I am thinking that the Power may not be able to charge up enough against a pretty impressive Bulldogs team, even in Darwin. The Bullies are the next best thing (to the top two teams that is) while the Power is almost the next worst thing. Territory heat and a neutral ground combined cannot make me place a tick against Port in this game. The Bulldogs kicked the sweep last week and might go close again this week.
Western Bulldogs by 33
Richmond V West Coast Eagles at Telstra Dome Saturday night
In the fixturing why has the AFL not scheduled a game for Saturday arvo just to maintain some tradition? Both Saturday's games are night games which plays havoc for tipsters and viewers who have Foxtel. Is a 6.40pm start in Darwin the same as a 7.10pm start in Melbourne? Anyway, if ever the footy gods smiled on a new coach it would have to be a grin of joy given to Rawlings of Richmond getting the gig against the Eagles as his first game to prove himself to the Tiger board. The Tigers have every chance to secure their 3rd win of the season and possibly jump ahead of the Eagles and Dockers on the ladder. What can I say? New coach, weak opposition, good odds, go Tigers! A point of interest in this game will be the debuts of two new ruckmen Natanui for West Coast and Vickery for the Tigers.
Richmond by 11
Hawthorn V Brisbane Lions somewhere in Tassie Sunday
This is the game of the round as very little separates the two teams in their current standings and while Brisbane continues to astound, the Hawks continue to confound. It's only the fact that the game is in Tasmania that I am inclined to go for Hawthorn but it would not surprise me to see the Lions take the game and the 4 points from them. I'm just not too sure what psychological depression Brisbane might find themselves in after last week's last gasp loss to the Blues and they will have to lift themselves not only mentally but physically as they also have to overcome the Tasmanian weather in contrast to sunny QLD which I can vouch for sitting here at the computer in a hotel in Rockhampton in shorts and T shirt while my buddies (and their bodies) freeze to death in the deserts of Kalgoorlie which, by the way, is not as cold as Tassie will be on Sunday. While the game is no gimmee for the Hawks the home and away ground reasoning bends me towards tipping them.
Hawthorn by 18
Adelaide V North Melbourne at AAMI on Sunday
I'm not about to eat crow again this week and even though I have the utmost respect for North Melbourne they are not in the same league as Adelaide at the moment who will be shooting for 4 in a row. Outside of Geelong and St Kilda no other team has been able to achieve that. The Crows look okay against teams of comparable ability to North, you know, weaker, so it will be a brave tipster who will pick against them in this match.
Adelaide Crows by 41
Essendon V Melbourne Friday night at Telstra Dome 19th June
If ever the Dees had a chance of winning a game this might be it but if they play any quarters of football like they did against the Pies last Monday then the Bombers will moider them. I'm thinking the Bombers will win anyway and with the extra week break they will have gotten over their feeble last quarter against the Crows. Young teams, lots of errors, won't be a classic game of Aussie Rules but it will be tight. I wouldn't be surprised to see Melbourne win the game but based on form and their relative levels of development Essendon is the favourite in this game. Another honourable loss to the Dees. I hope young Jack plays better in this game.
Essendon by 12
Sydney V Collingwood at ANZ Stadium Saturday night
The statistics say that Collingwood has won more of these games played at the old Olympic stadium than the Swans. Who cares about that? What we want to know is can they win this one? It's a shame Barry Hall gave away the 3 x 50 metre penalties last week against Hawthorn because I reckon the Pies will sorely need one at some time in this game. The Maggies are getting a few back from injury and with an extra week up their sleeve who knows, they might even have Medhurst return as well to the forward line. The Swans like to play it tough and tight and so do the Pies and if the weather is that little bit wet and slippery look out for a slugfest. My Foxtel will be connected by then so I should be able to watch the game live. Collingwood have a bit of a thing going at the moment with consecutive wins so here's hoping they can maintain the momentum. It will be a close game.
Collingwood by 11
Fremantle V Geelong at Subiaco Sunday arvo
A premiership one year followed by a loss in the grand final the following year and your reward is two trips in 2 games to Perth?! I predicted the Cats would kick the sweep last week against the Eagles but I was probably a round out with that call. Freo do not have a chance of winning this game regardless of how badly the Cats play. Say no more the tip is clear. I might just tone down a bit on the margin.
Geelong by 45
---------------------------------------------------------------
The AFL Preview is sent via an automatic email list. To join or leave the list is easy.
Please visit our website at http://www.footy.com.au/fts/newsletters.htm
OR
If you have difficulty with the above please email lists@footy.com.au
[AFL-Review] AFL Round 11
AFL Round 11 - Remember it?
Of all the issues confronting footy, very few have addressed the most important: who can make the best joke involving Collywood's Brad Dick. The best one I've heard so far is
At Docklands:
Footscray 4.2 11.6 18.10 24.13.157
Plough's last game in charge of the Tiges followed a recent pattern for the Big Pu55ies; a competitive half, over-run in the other. Jade Rawlings, coach of the Tiges' VFL affiliate
Slow start, both sides playing man-on-man and trying to maintain an open forward-line. It led to heavy midfield congestion and multiple turnovers as both sides tried to move the ball with too much handpassing, the Tiggers especially. Bully Josh Hill missed the best early chance before the Tiggers scored the first goal, ten minutes in. Captain Chris Newman ran down Nathan Eagleton to force a turnover and soon Ben Cousins - fined 10K for his raised middle finger to a TV camera last week - kicked long where Mitch Morton marked alone in the goal-square and popped it through. The Dogs replied soon as Toig backman Luke McGuane's wobbly clearing kick was marked by Bully Jarrod Harbrow, he chipped inboard to Adam Cooney whose pass to leading Brad Johnson was spoiled by Will Thursfield, but roving Hill gathered and slotted. A long Eagleton shot hit the post and Commetti quipped that "Dogs love posts." The Tiggers put together a good rebound and Trent Cotchin ran ahead and directed some traffic before passing to leading Morton, who duly marked and booted his second. The Dogs replied again, ruckman Will Minson whacked a throw-in towards the corridor, Ryan Hargrave gathered and slipped a handball to Shaun Higgins who snapped a classy left-footed sausage. Bully Daniel 'Guido' Giansiracusa punted the Dogs into attack from the restart, the ball cleared Hill but running Callan Ward collected the pill and jabbed a goal. The Doggies led by 6 points. Back came the Tiges from a throw-in in their forward-pocket, Bulldog Matthew Boyd was tackled while kicking and his punt travelled about 5m, Shane Tuck gathered for the Tiges and handballed for the ubiquitous Morton to snap another. The Bullies went ahead again, an under-pressure Giansiracusa stabbed a low, mongrelled kick straight to Jason Akermanis, probably intentional, and Aker converted. The Tiges tied up the scores once more before korter-time, Brett Deledio dropped a mark on-the-lead but roving Cousins hooked a punt to the top o' the 'square where Jack Riewoldt judged it smartly to mark at the back of the pack and boot truly. Late in the term commentator Nathan Buckley mentioned the Tiges' propensity to start games well but drop off in intensity and effort later in the contest. Prescient. Come coach us, Bucks!
Into the second term and it appeared as though Bucks's prediction was coming true already. Richmun did bag an early major, Bulldog Ward's risky centering kick caused a turnover and Cotchin had a quick snap, it dropped short but the ball came to Riewoldt who poked it through. But the Bullpups scored six of the next seven goals, with cleaner handling and better disposal than the Tiges. They reclaimed the lead, Johnson missed a shot but the Tiges' untidy kick-in went to Daniel Cross just outside the 50, a quick switch-of-play and Boyd booted a running major. Following some volleyball in the centre Cooney escaped with the Sherrin, he kicked wide to Johnson who in turn punted quickly into space for Mitch Hahn to take a with-the-flight grab, Hahn ran on and dobbed a goal. The Bullies led by 8 points as the Tiggers answered, some scrap on the boundary-line saw the ball emerge with Morton, his centering kick was collected on-the-bounce by
The Dogs put their collective paws down after half-time. Their mistakes dried up, their tackling pressure went up, the Tiges dropped off and made more mistakes. Just as Bucks'd predicted, although you could factor in the Tiges' six-day break and
The Doggies' midfield dominated after half-time, led by Adam Cooney (33 disposals, 4 marks, a goal) whose recent lift in form has accompanied that of the Dogs' in general. Jarrod Harbrow (28 touches, 6 marks) is proving a handy on-baller and Shaun Higgins (20 possessions, 6 marks, 3 goals) is a class act. Liam Picken (15 touches, 3 marks, 2 goals) bettered Deledio and Callan Ward (17 touches, 4 marks, a goal) is establishing his spot in the side. Regular performers Matthew Boyd (28 possies, a goal) and Brad Johnson (21 disposals, 8 marks, 2 goals) were handy. Daniel Giansiracusa, Lindsay Gilbee and Mitch Hahn kicked 2 goals each, overall eighteen of the twenty-two Dogs kicked goals in the game. Best of the Tiges were their combative on-ballers Daniel Jackson (30 disposals, 8 marks) and Nathan Foley (30 possessions). Captain Chris Newman (25 possies, 5 marks) had a good battle with Johnson and Shane Tuck (32 disposals, 8 marks, 2 goals) won plenty of it as usual, youngster Andrew Collins (24 touches, 4 marks, a goal) played well again. Jack Riewoldt and Mitch Morton kicked 3 first-half goals each, Adam Pattison bagged 2 goals. Plough said "(Turnovers) have been the problem with the footy club more than any other problem. Until that can be rectified, that's by personnel or by practice, the club won't take the steps forward that it wants to take." You couldn't fix it in four-and-a-half years? "I can't remember a worse result than that. I think after half-time ten of their thirteen goals came from direct turnovers," continued Wallace. "It's very, very difficult to sit in the coaches' box and be able to do anything in regards to that. That's a long-term thing; it's a 'have you got the right people?'; 'do you need to have better decision makers and kickers involved in your team?' Or do you have to have strategies in place that don't allow you to be so flippant with your turnovers? . . . There are a lot of issues that the club has got to look at but we haven't run out games at all. [But] when you keep turning the footy over that makes you look like you're not running out games because it's all downhill running from there." 'Rocket' Eade said "Our execution early in the game was poor and at some stages in the second quarter but our execution in the third quarter matched our ability to put pressure on. We worked hard, and once you work hard the skill tends to follow . . . I thought some of the young players really set the scene there . . . I thought Picken, and I thought Ward's pressure and his hard-ball gets in that third quarter were terrific. Harbrow [was also good]. So I think those younger players were as much the catalysts as anybody." Rocket was asked if Plough's quitting had been a distraction.
"I think it gave us a bit more focus," he said. "I mean, coming off three or four good performances, you're always worried about players lapsing a bit, especially playing against a team that's second-last. I think with the focus on the departure of Terry, I think it just brought our players [together]. We spoke to them obviously on Monday - not in a big way. And there's obviously history between the two clubs and we spoke about that as well, but I think from that aspect it was probably a positive."
At Docklands:
St. Kilda 1.3 4.7 8.10 15.13.103
Substitute players were on the agenda again after the
Norf came out fired-up and determined to 'get in the face' of the Sainters, collectively. Adam Simpson, Scott McMahon and Michael Firrito led the aggression, Simpson and Brady Rawlings won the contested ball, the
Sainters Luke Ball and Dal Santo lifted after half-time, but it was still a battle as the Kangers hung in. Gibson and Firrito led a tough Roo defence but their midfield rotations were in trouble with Power and
The in-form Lenny Hayes (32 disposals, 8 tackles) and 'fringe player' Jason Gram (31 handlings, 5 marks, a goal) were the Saints' best performers over the entire game, with Justin Koschitzke (10 marks, 14 disposals, 6 goals) doing some powerful finishing work in attack. Nick Dal Santo (26 touches, 6 tackles, a goal) and Luke Ball (22 handlings) came into it after half-time, as did Leigh Montagna (27 possessions). Clint Jones (19 disposals, a goal) did well on Wells and Andrew McQualter (21 possies, 7 tackles) was handy in the clinches, Nick Riewoldt (15 kicks, 14 marks, 3 goals) finished a handy contributor despite being beaten by Gibson for three quarters. Adam Schneider bagged 2 goals. Norf's fight was carried by Adam Simpson (21 disposals, a goal) and Michael Firrito (18 touches, 7 marks, a goal) in the middle and Josh Gibson (14 touches, 6 marks) on Riewoldt. Scott McMahon (21 touches, 6 marks) was very good running off half-back, for the first half anyway, and Daniel Pratt (18 possies, 10 marks) made a welcome return. Hamish McIntosh (8 disposals, 40 hit-outs) rucked solidly, Andrew Swallow kicked 2 goals. Dean Laidley's comments were justified if predictable. "We lost two players before half time and then ran around in the last quarter with seventeen players on the ground with two blokes who probably shouldn't have been out there. It's a monumental effort," Laidley said. "Benny Warren went down and Sam Power got whacked. We had Matty [
At the Gabba:
The Fev booted 8 goals while Jonathan Brown could only manage 4 from ten shots as the Bluies scored a very handy win in Brisbun. The Blooze controlled possession for three quarters while the Lyin's were unusually sluggish, and by the time they got moving in the final stanza, it was too late. Lyin' coach Michael Voss struggled too. In his defence, the absence of three regular Lyin' defenders was exposed here. The Brisbun side had one change from the one which defeated the
The Blooze midfield continued to dominate into the third korter, while Black, Brennan and Brown played lone hands for the Lyin's. Voss rolled the dice by switching Bradshaw to full-forward to aid the beleaguered Brown, while Joel Macdonald picked up Fevola. A move Voss probably had to make, but it didn't really work out. Within thirty seconds of the korter starting Fevola had a goal, a free-kick for being held back on a lead by Macdonald. Soft, but it was there. Brown added to his points-tally by postering after noice work from Brennan to make the chance. Bluie Fisher executed a skilful pick-up and handball to O'hAilpin, the Irishman jabbed a short pass for leading Fevola to mark and thump through from 45m. The Bluies led by a healthy 28 points, now. The Lyin's hung in, Brown seized a very good mark in front of
The Brians mounted a challenge in the final term as Black finally received some midfield help from the likes of Adcock, Power and
No doubt Brendan Fevola (18 disposals, 8 marks, 8.3) was the Bluies' main man here, with key midfield efforts from a cool Bryce Gibbs (27 disposals), consistent Chris Judd (28 touches, a goal) and battlin' Marc Murphy (25 possessions). Paul Bower (25 touches, 9 marks) did well at full-back and during some contests with Brown and Dennis Armfield (22 disposals, 4 marks) was indeed fast and feisty. Aaron Joseph (5 disposals) won kudos again, for his stopping effort on dangerous Rhan Hooper. Best of the Lyin's were Simon Black (33 disposals, 5 marks, a goal) and Jared Brennan (24 touches, 4 marks, 4 goals). Jonathan Brown (19 disposals, 13 marks) got the ball a lot but his final tally of 4.5 and an out-on-the-full didn't hurt the Bluies enough. Luke Power (26 disposals, 2 goals) played alright and Mitch Clark (15 handlings, 6 marks, 33 hit-outs) performed solidly in the ruck again. The papers give Justin Sherman (21 possies, a goal) a mention, but he didn't do much. Daniel Bradshaw kicked 2 goals. "We played a very safe brand of football, we didn't challenge the opposition in any way whatsoever and in some ways got dictated to in how the game was played," Voss said. "Once we decided to change that around and have a different attitude to how we moved the ball, then the game started to turn on its head and the pressure was back on
At
Port
Fremantle 4.2 8.2 10.4 11.4.70
Port did what they had to, winning a home game over a depleted Fremandle unit. But the Dokkers were plenty competitive in the first half and there were shades of the same fixture in 2008, when the Powder were turned-over by a Pavlich-less Freo who booted six goals to none in the first quarter. But the Flowers found some backbone and it didn't end like that, this time. In selection the Flowers dropped unfit men Chad Cornes and Matt Thomas (knee injuries both) while Nathan Krakouer was plain dropped and Robbie Gray missed with gastro. In came Justin Westhoff, first game back from a fractured ankle if I recall, Josh Carr, Toby Thurstans and Marlon Motlop - still no Daniel, though. The Dockulaters lost Des Headland (thigh strain), Luke McPharlin (corked hip), Michael Johnson (rolled ankle) and Antoni Grover (calf muscle strain) following the carnage against the Tiges. Their replacements were Kepler Bradley, Adam Campbell and two first-gamers, rookie-listed defender Clancee Pearce of Swan Districts and midfielder Michael Walters from Midvale, also via Swan Districts.
'Twas wet at
Goals continued to alternate into the third, but Port pulled away late in the stanza, just after a torrential burst of rain hit the ground. In what was becoming the night of the rookies, Powderman Marlon Motlop ran onto a crumb from Ebert's contest and tip-toed into the goal-square to poke a sausage, his career-first goal following those of Freo's Walters and Pearce. Port led by 4 points. A bit later Sandilands punted the Doccers into attack, the ball spilled from Ibbotson's contest and the Powdermen laid some heavy tackles before Dokka de Boer got a handball to David Mundy, who booted a goal. Freo led by 3 points. Port at last managed consecutive goals, Justin Westhoff dithered hopelessly and was tackled while kicking but his brother Matthew collected the sprayed kick and lobbed a punt into the corridor, 20m out, where Danyle Pearce arrived to gather and snap a major. Then Rodan, whose best form is in wet weather, gathered Brogan's ruck-tap on the 50m line, sold a dummy, slipped another tackle and booted a tremendous running goal from 40m. That seemed to wake 'em up. Pavlich missed a shot before Port's Pearce ran hard to gather the ball just inside the boundary, he hooked a quick punt forward which Freo's Dodd fisted down but Matthew Westhoff soccered ahead, ran on to receive Tredrea's handball and Matthew Westhoff worked some space for himself before hooking a terrific snap for a great goal. Three straight majors for Port and they led by 14 points. Freo pulled one back, Pavlich out-bodied Chaplin to take a very good grab behind the Port man and boot a noice goal from 55m, albeit right in front. But then Motlop roved a throw-in at half-forward and slipped a handball to Kane Cornes, who ran clear and booted a six-pointer. The Flowers scrambled the ball forward from the restart and it was Rodan again, who eventually scooped up the ball on the attacking side of the centre-square, slipped diving Duffield's tackle and ran on to boot another very good sausage. Port led by 20 points at the final change and took firm charge with an early goal in the ultimate korter, a backwards-handballing Freo move came unstuck when Dodd was tackled by Tredrea, Dodd's wild one was gathered by Chaplin who handballed to Ebert, he snapped it through. Port led by 26 points now, a coupla behinds made it 28. Freo did manage a goal a few minutes later, Pord's Cornes slipped over deep in defence and fired a panicky handball away, there was some scrap before Lower's desperate clearing kick went straight to Mundy who booted the major. There were still thirteen minutes to go after that, but a
Nuggetty rover David Rodan (19 disposals, 3 goals) provided the inspiration for Port, with the perspiration coming from Kane Cornes (34 touches, a goal) who had the better of Paul Hasleby. Ruckman Brendon Lade (17 possies, 12 marks, a goal) was a very useful around-the-ground performer and Troy Chaplin (14 touches, 4 marks, a goal) shaded Pavlich, the Freo talisman is not having the best of seasons. Dom Cassisi (27 disposals, 10 tackles) was also good in midfield and there were handy contributions from full-back Toby Thurstans (24 touches, 6 marks), half-back Jacob Surjan (25 handlings, 7 marks) and lean forward Justin Westhoff (13 kicks, 10 marks, 2 goals). Ruckman Aaron Sandilands (20 disposals, 6 marks, 27 hit-outs) was probably Freo's best although he didn't kick any goals. And took out a forward. Runnin' rebounder Paul Duffield (29 disposals) was good again, as was junior Greg Broughton (22 possies) who plays a similar role. Byron Schammer (22 handlings) and wingman Andrew Foster (13 touches) played well, David Mundy (22 disposals, 2 goals) lurked about as usual and left you with the feeling he could've done more. Debutants Michael Walters and Clancee Pearce had 14 and 16 disposals respectively and kicked a goal each, so that was good. Harvs focused on such positives. "I think that our younger group will in time more than hold its own. We've been through a lot in 18 months and it will hold us in good stead,"
At Docklands:
Essendon 5.3 10.4 16.4 18.6.114
Amazing, straight-shooting goal-fest at the Docklands in which the Camrys just out-stayed the Bommers. Last year it would've taken three games for the Cows to score 24 goals but they and Craig deserve some credit for finally managing some more attacking football, and unearthing some apparently reliable forwards. Bomba coach Knights has always maintained an 'attack and enjoy now, learn defence later' philosophy which has brought some exciting wins for his young side, but also some very frustrating losses, like this one. Coming in, the Dons made four changes to the side slaughtered by
The Dons made the early running in the shootout. Sole remaining ruckman Paddy Ryder kicked the first goal after marking Dempsey's pass, then Jobe Watson booted the Bummers into attack from the restart and Don supporters were gladdened as Scott Lucas, sporting a new 'serious' haircut, collected the ball on-the-bounce and bagged a goal. Tight for a while but the Dons were tackling hard and exerting much pressure, curbing the Camrys' new desire for attacking run. Camry Bernie Vince free-kicked a goal after he was tackled without the ball, but the Dons went forward from the restart and Sam Lonergan handballed for Watson to punt a running major from outside (or maybe just on) the 50m line. Now that's uncanny. Matty Lloyd missed a shot but soon Watson kicked another goal, slipping forward to be found by Alwyn Davey's smart pass. A bit later leading Kyle Reimers had a free after being shoved in the back Corolla defender Graham 'Stiffy' Johncock, Reimers dished off to Ricky Dyson who thumped a major from 55m. The Dons led by 26 points, 5.2 to Vince's goal for the Camrys. But the visitors bagged a coupla late ones, Scott Thompson lobbed a hopeful kick in where Pat Dangerfield out-maneuvered McPhee to mark on his chest and actually kick a goal from a difficult spot. Then Edwards's kick found Camry big man Kurt Tippett in a huge amount of space, Tippett lumbered onto the ball, dummied around Ryder in slow-motion and snapped a sausage roll. The Donnies led by 15 points at korter-time. Someone inside the Docklands' bowels messed up, as rain tumbled down through the open roof during the second quarter. The Camrys' midfield got moving in the second term led by a huge effort from Edwards and supported by some great forward play from Tippett. But the Dons stayed in front for quite a while. Lucas booted the first goal of the second stanza after Camry ruckman Ivan Maric was penalized for slapping a ball-up through for a rushed Bommer behind. That seemed a very wrong decision, but in the spirit of the rule I 'spose it was correct. The Cows scored the next two goals though, Johncock's pass found Tippett lurking alone in the pocket for a mark and goal, then, in what's becoming a weekly highlight, running Camry Chris Knights thundered a kick from inside the centre-square for anuge sausage, the ball bounced right on the goal-line. Great tackle from Michael Doughty on Watson to create that one. The Bommer lead was reduced to 9 points, Lloyd missed a shot before Adam McPhee gathered Monfries's kick superbly on the half-volley, McPhee's tumbling snap from the forward pocket bounced and rolled through for a great goal. But the Cressidas closed further with two more goals from Tippett, the first was banana-ed - sorry, check-sided through from the boundary-line after leading to mark Bock's pass, a minute later Tippett steered a conventional drop-punt between the big poles from the opposite pocket, following a with-the-flight grab ahead of Lucas and McPhee. The Dons' lead was just 4 points now but they stayed ahead as the goal-scoring alternated to half-time. Former Camry Hayden Skipworth free-kicked a goal for the Dons after being slung to the ground by Scott Thompson at a throw-in, a bit later Tippett lined-up again from 55m, his shot dropped short but roving Jason Porplyzia handballed for Andrew McLeod to snap a major. Bombout Watson then snapped his third goal, thanks to a great handpass from Lonergan. At the other end Tippett tapped a throw-in down to Knights who snapped truly, but the stanza ended with another Bomma goal as Lloyd picked off Edwards's centering kick and Brent Stanton passed for unopposed Lucas to mark 30m out and dob a major. Dons by 10 points at the long rest.
The frenetic and highly accurate scoring continued into the third term, both sides obviously happy to engage in a shootout. The roof was closed now. First it was the Corollas, Bommer Andrew Lovett slipped which allowed Knights an easy mark of Stevens's kick and typically long goal. A bit later Lucas did very well to engage in some handball receive-and-give on the wing, then run forward to call for and receive a pass from Monfries. Lucas goaled, Bommers by 10. Adderlayed scored their first behind at this stage, a rushed one to boot. Essadun drew away a bit, Camry Richard Douglas gathered a loose ball deep in defence but fired a hot handball which went through McLeod's hands, Bomma Lonergan's handpass allowed Mark McVeigh to curl a great left-foot snap through from the pocket. A bit later Jay Neagle was clattered as he led to a pass but the ump waved play-on, to advantage as Lonergan gathered the ball and handballed ahead for 'cheating' Lovett to stab an easy six-pointer. The Dons led by 21 points, the largest differential for a while. Back came the Coronas though, Tippett led out to clutch a strong grab in front of poor ol' Cale Hooker and punt a goal, a bit later McPhee's terrible handpass at half-back went straight to Camry Vince and he handballed for Taylor Walker to score full points with a great left-foot snap. Essadun by 9 points but they scored the next goal, Corolla Andy Otten's great tackle on Davey forced the ball loose but Bomma Kyle Reimers gathered and snapped truly. The Camrys drew closer again with the next two goals, great running from Maric for the first as he rucked at the centre-bounce following the Reimers goal, then ran down to the goal-square as Moran roved Knights's long kick and got a handball away for Maric to snap a sausage. Then it was Tippett again, clattered head-on by the hapless Hooker as Johncock's long kick came in. A free-kick and 50m penalty for Tippett as Hooker whinged, Tippett duly slotted his sixth goal and the Don lead was reduced to 3 points. The Dons found something again, Camry man Bock did very well to smother Lonergan's kick but he followed up by diving on Monfries's back and Monfries free-kicked a goal. Addleaid's
Tyson Edwards (41 disposals, 8 marks, 10 tackles) played a beauty on his milestone and Kurt Tippett's 7 goals (from 9 marks, 11 kicks) were hailed as a breakthrough, although it remains to be seen if he can be a consistent goal-scorer. Certainly Chris Knights (22 touches, 5 marks, 5 goals) has been that since the Cows adopted their new style. Bernie Vince (36 possies, 7 marks, a goal) and Scott Thompson (33 handlings, 6 marks) played well in midfield while backmen Nathan Bock (25 disposals, 5 marks) and Graham 'Stiffy' Johncock (22 possies, 6 marks) engaged in plenty of aggressive rebound running, Bock also kept Matty Lloyd goal-less. Taylor Walker and Richard Douglas kicked 2 goals each. For the Dons, running midfielders Brent Stanton (31 disposals, 6 marks) and Andrew Lovett (31 touches, 3 marks, a goal) enjoyed the open, attacking game and Jobe Watson (26 disposals, 5 marks, 3 goals) was very good, especially early before Doughty established some degree of control. Hayden Skipworth (21 touches, 2 goals) enjoyed playing against his old side and Ricky Dyson (17 disposals, a goal) would appear to have improved. But go easy. Brent Prismall (19 touches, 4 marks) made a handy debut, Sam Lonergan (21 possies) did some tough work and Bachar Houli (26 possies) was handy again as a running back-pocket. Scott Lucas (18 disposals, 6 marks) bagged 4 opportunistic goals as he swapped between the forward-line and being Tippett's opponent, Angus Monfries kicked 2 goals. Matty Knights was asked to comment on the fact that neither Lloyd nor Neagle kicked a goal. "Lloydy had his hands full (with Bock) there and he'll live to fight another day. But Lloydy has been really good for us in the first half of the year," Knights said. "He's done an enormous amount of work and we have to pay him and McPhee a lot of credit, because they're the two senior players that we've had one at either end [of the ground], playing with the younger guys . . . (Neagle) was disappointing today, but . . . he's a really promising player in my view. We felt in last week's game his meaningful leads were up and he worked really hard against the best defence in the competition in
At the MCG:
Hawthorn 4.5 7.5 9.11 12.14.86
Big, Bad, Bustlin', Brain-snappin' Barry Hall grabbed all the headlines here, coughing up three consecutive 50m penalties with a series of verbals and arm-flailing handbags in the last quarter which handed the Orcs a goal and virtually the game, in what was a tight one at the 'G. Hall was a bit hard done-by but his reputation precedes him, and the Hawthorn players wound him up expertly. Afterwards team-mates Adam Goodes and Brett Kirk singled out the incident as game-deciding. But it was a gutsy win from the Hawks, as they continue to struggle to put players on the ground; Luke Hodge returned here but Campbell Brown (corked thigh) and Thomas Murphy (gastro) were late withdrawals, during the game Cyril Rioli suffered a bad hamstring injury which may keep him out for two months. Ruckman Brent Renouf also returned for the Awks, Travis Tuck and Ryan Schoenmakers were recalled while Brendan Whitecross and Jarryd Morton were dropped.
At a grey, drizzly 'G the Hawks started well as Lance 'Buddy' Franklin ran off the back of the centre-square to gather and run inside 50, he handballed poorly to Rioli who was scragged anyway by Jared Crouch. Rioli dished off his free by handballing to Jarryd Roughead, who booted a long goal. But the Swans, victors over the Hawks earlier in the year, responded well, if inaccurately. Adam Goodes and Darren Jolly missed shots before Marty Mattner bombed a long goal, after Jude Bolton roved pack-spillage. The wet, slippery conditions didn't help and about now Rioli tore his hamstring, bumped low and slipping over as he roved a pack. There's been speculation since that Rioli's increased midfield workload, caused by the Awks' other injuries, had increased wear-and-tear on the teenagers' body. Maybe, it's hard to know. After a few more points some slither led to the next goal, a carnival of slipping and fumbling on Horforn's forward-flank ended with Swan Ted Richards coat-hangering Mark Williams, Williams opened the angle and hooked his free-kick for a goal. Goodes missed again before Swan Rhyce Shaw chased down a long Horforn kick into his own backline, Shaw gathered and hooked a punt clear but only as far as Williams, who produced a smart hook-kick of his own for
Into the third term and the Swans began to grind back into the contest, led by Goodes and Ryan O'Keefe. In the opening minute O'Loughlin seized a strong grab of Jude Bolton's free-kick and booted a major. A few minutes later O'Loughlin led wide to take a great mark under pressure from Hodge and Brent Guerra, O'Loughlin played-on immediately and punted to the goal-square, Orc Simon Taylor couldn't hold a juggling grab and Goodes grabbed the pill to snap a major. Horforn's lead was reduced to 5 points. Taylor and Franklin missed shots for the Horks before Michael Osborne ran onto the flank to take a with-the-flight grab of McGlynn's kick, Osborne passed quickly for leading Franklin to mark and steer a major from the pocket. Sewell punted the Awks into attack from the following centre-bounce, Swan Mattner slipped over allowing Xavier Ellis to take an uncontested grab, Ellis played-on immediately and slotted. A brace of rushed behinds had the Orcs 22 points ahead, but the Swans scored two late sausage rolls. Hall had been denied an earlier mark-and-goal for tugging Robert Campbell's guernsey and now Bazza dropped Moore's handpass, but Hall re-gathered, ducked a coupla tackles and kicked to the goal-square, Goodes couldn't mark under pressure from Hodge but Kirk grabbed the spilled ball and snapped it through, he roared and engaged in much fist-pumping. A bit later Heath 'Reg' Grundy had a free-kick from a marking contest and punted long, Hall leaped for a fairly easy mark as the Hawkers looked about at each-other. Hall converted and the Horforn lead was reduced to 10 points at the final change. Early in the final Mario Goodes put a solid bump on McGlynn, causing the Hawk man to drop the ball and Goodes then dived to force the agget over to Shaw, he chipped a pass for Jolly to mark and boot a good, long major. A minute or two later Kirk handballed for Kieran Jack to punt long and Goodes was awarded a free for Hodge's arm-chopping in the marking contest, Goodes converted and Siddey were in-front, by 2 points, having scored the last four goals of the game. Some rugged minutes followed before Williams sent the Hawks ahead again, in the centre
Hawk ruck-rover Brad Sewell (24 disposals) enjoyed the wet conditions and up forward Lance 'Buddy' Franklin (17 disposals, 9 marks, 3 goals) attacked the ball better than he has done for much of the season. Sam Mitchell (20 touches, 6 marks, a goal) worked hard in and around the many packs, Brent Guerra (11 touches) did some rebound running and Luke Hodge (23 disposals, 6 marks) had a great battle with Goodes, although the Siddey man shaded him in the end. Jordan Lewis (20 possies, 6 marks) did well around the ground and Robert Campbell deserves credit for holding Hall to 2 goals. Jarryd Roughead (15 touches, 6 marks) and Mark Williams were handy in booting 3 goals each, Xavier Ellis bagged 2 handy goals. Adam Goodes (23 disposals, 4 marks, 3 goals) is having a great year for Siddey, and he's a renowned Brownlow vote-collector. Ryan O'Keefe (26 touches, 6 marks) played very well again, ruckman Darren Jolly (17 handlings, 6 marks, 35 hit-outs, a goal) and rover (I suppose he is) Jude Bolton (17 possies, 12 tackles, a goal) were good and Jarrad McVeigh (21 disposals, 6 marks, a goal) was handy. Michael O'Loughlin (15 touches, 7 marks, a goal) played well in attack, could've kicked more goals, maybe. Barry Hall kicked 2 goals. And conceded one. Everyone wanted to ask about Hall's madness. Were you going to win, Roosy? "We were never over-confident because they're the premiership team and they've got some really good players that are hungry at the moment. They've got some good forwards as well. I didn't think we'd get overrun, but we certainly had the momentum and looked good early in the last quarter." Adam Goodes wasn't as cagey. "We had them in the last quarter. We had them running all over the place, we were getting it in our forward line, we looked really dangerous and we were creating scoring opportunities," Goodes said. "The game was definitely there to be won, and once we hit the lead I felt really positive about kicking on. I know other players did as well. We're definitely playing good enough football but there are a lot of areas where we can improve." Hmm. Al Clarkson reflected on a good win but more injuries. "It's a very, very fine line between pleasure and pain, isn't it," Clarkson said. "Fortunately for us, we were in front at the right time . . . we showed a fair amount of character and spirit to fight our way back into the contest in the last quarter when we had some pretty sore and sorry players and it looked like
At Subiaco:
West Coast 1.3 5.6 8.9 11.11.77
The Cats sprang outta the blocks but struggled after korter-time, facing up to a committed effort from the Weegs. Or you could accept the view of several meedya pundits, that the Cats coasted in third gear for the remainder. The Weegs' poor disposal going forward was again a problem but they tackled hard and produced a much better performance then the corresponding fixture in 2008, in which
The Pu55ies fired outta the blocks, just like 2008. Cameron Ling was given a free-kick secondary to the opening bounce, he handballed for Joel Selwood to pass for diving 'Tomahawk' Tom Hawkins to mark and boot a goal. A minute later Jimmy Bartel gathered on the wing and passed to leading Steve Johnson, he lobbed a handball for Gary Ablett to run inside 50 and assess options before potting the major himself. The Wiggles hung in there for a bit, before a slick Pu55y move ended with Hawkins goaling from a free-kick. Catter ruckman Shane Mumford had a free at the restart, he handballed off to Selwood who lobbed one into space for either Paul Chapman or Shannon Byrnes to collect, Byrnes got there first, ran inside the 50, dummied 'round Eric Mackenzie and speared another Catter major. A minute later Mumford and Selwood won the agget again from a ball-up, Chapman lobbed a kick forward which Ryan Gamble gathered and snapped a goal. The Cats led by 31 points, 5.1 to nought-nought. But the Eegs began to get into it, led by Dean 'Big' Cox and Matt Priddis. Tyson Stenglein was assigned the job on Steve Johnson and the Weeg veteran went on to do a very good job. Cox and Andrew Embley scored behinds for the Weegs, before Cox grabbed the ball cleanly from a throw-in an snapped a major. Geelagong still led by 22 points at the first break, though. Into quartier le deuxieme and a flurry of early goals, Weegle Josh Kennedy was paid a backpedalling chest-mark which he and Cat Tom Lonergan (deployed as a defender here) appeared to grab simultaneously, but Kennedy's it was and he booted a simple goal. The Katz replied as Joel Selwood ambled forward, swapped handballs with Ling and passed for leading Cameron Mooney to take a diving mark, Moons majored. Then it were the Weegs again, Mark LeCras won the ball well against Matty Scarlett and tumbled a quick punt forward, Quinten Lynch held off Milburn to juggle a one-handed grab and steer it through from the boundary-line. The Pu55ies goaled in turn, Embley was hopelessly caught in possession near his defensive point-post and Travis Varcoe hooked the resulting free for a major. Cats by 22 points still after those, but at least the Weegs were scoring now. They crept closer, Chris Masten ran down the flank and lobbed a punt to the top o' the 'square where Mitch Brown, normally a backman, took an uncontested grab as the Cat defenders looked at each-other. Brown popped it through. A couple of misses each over the next ten minutes before the Weegs' Brown bagged another goal, the Weegs had the classical loose men everywhere as Scott Selwood punted forward and Embley chipped a centering pass for Brown to mark in-stride, run-on and spear it through. The Weevils had reduced their deficit to 11 points at half-time.
The low sun was a problem for Wiggle forwards (and Cat backmen) into the third term, they were looking into it as the ball came in. Lynch dropped a mark as he was confounded by the sun, roving Kennedy snapped a behind. Catter James Kelly was also troubled by the sun as he stabbed the resulting kick-in straight to LeCras, who missed awfully. The Wiggles were putting good pressure on though, as they tried to run outta defence Cats Scarlett and Ablett made a mess of things and Lynch gathered to loosed ball to snap truly, it bounced through reducing the Pu55ies' lead to 3 points. The Cats replied as David Wojcinski's long clearing kick found Gamble on the wing, he handballed ahead to Byrnes who delivered a pass to leading Steve Johnson, Johnson steered a major from the flank. Tight for a while as the Weegs had a crack, before the Cats manufactured a goal. Jimmy Bartel hacked an under-pressure kick forward which Hawkins marked, he handballed off to running Nathan Djerrkura whose low, wobbly punt found Ablett in front of his man for a mark and goal. Mathew Stokes missed poorly, to have the Katz 15 points up. The Weevils hit back after some tough work from Darren Glass to clear the backline, Brad Ebert roved LeCras's contest and lobbed a punt for Ben McKinley to mark against Kelly. McKinley goaled and the gap was back to 9 points. But the Catters now produced another punishing burst of scoring, Varcoe's great, long run from the very last line of defence sent the ball towards leading Johnson, Stenglein spoiled but Stokes roved the contest and kicked towards Paul Chapman who bullocked his way past two Wiggle backmen and snapped a major. The Pu55ies won the following centre-clearance and Mooney led up to mark on the 50m line, he kicked smartly for Chapman to mark behind the pack and slot another. Chapman, having a purple patch, then missed a fairly easy snap which he wasn't happy about. A bit later Eeg Jamie McNamara gathered the ball from a throw-in on the wing and took off, he had a bounce and approached the 50 - his side's defensive 50, McNamara was going the wrong way! Despite the yelling of his team-mates and the crowd, McNamara actually kicked 'forward', at which point he realized his mistake. McNamara sprinted down and tried to recover the ball, but too late, Catter Byrnes bagged a goal. Oops.
Joel Selwood (26 disposals, 5 marks) was once again a terrific ball-winner for the Catters. Paul Chapman (24 disposals, 5 marks, 3 goals) was crucial in the second half in keeping the Cats ahead and Gary Ablett (43 touches, 10 marks, 2 goals) collected a phenomenal amount of touches, but not all of them were especially damaging with all the Cats' heavy handball circle-work. Matty Scarlett (21 possessions, 8 marks) was terrific in an unusually under-manned Cat back-line with good efforts coming from Corey Enright (26 touches, 6 marks) and David Wojcinki (14 disposals) too, Shannon Byrnes (19 handlings, 2 goals) and Travis Varcoe (23 touches, a goal) did some good things further afield. Encouraging signs from Tom Hawkins (11 possies, 7 marks, 3 goals). Responding to accusations of kick-chasing, Weegle ruckman Dean 'Big' Cox (28 disposals, 7 marks, 32 hit-outs, a goal) asserted himself more and Tyson Stenglein (21 disposals) did a great job on Cat match-winner Steve Johnson. Matt Priddis (21 possessions) and Brad Ebert (16 touches, 9 tackles) did solid jobs in midfield and Adam Hunter (26 disposals) showed improved form as he stayed more in defence this time. Shannon Hurn (22 possessions) was handy running from defence and Darren Glass held Mooney to one goal and few marks, Adam Selwood (23 disposals) battled away against Ablett. Mitch Brown, Quinten Lynch and Ben McKinley kicked 2 goals each. John Worsfold confessed to being worried after the opening quarter-hour. "Once the game settled, the boys were very good. There were a lot of really positive things in the game that the players deserve credit for, but there's a lot of areas that we need to keep working (on). The players' resolve to not get flustered by the bad start and to keep taking it up to
At the MCG:
Collingwood 7.4 10.7 16.11 19.12.126
The
Terrible first quarter for the Deez, who handballed too often and not very well. Plus the Pies' midfielders, led by leather-magnet Dane Swan and Scott Pendlebury, controlled the contested ball and the Pies used it longer and smarter.
The
Skinny but agile Pie forward Brad Dick (16 disposals, 5 marks, 5 goals) was the star of the game but Scott Pendlebury (39 possessions, 11 marks, a goal) and Dane Swan (32 disposals, 7 marks, a goal) provided the Poise drive from midfield. Alan Didak (33 disposals, 4 marks, 2 goals) was very good, wandering about from half-forward and Josh Fraser (27 touches, 7 marks) played well as an extra midfielder, more than a ruckman. Heath Shaw (30 possies, 10 marks) produced another solid game in defence, Sharrod Wellingham (19 touches, 5 marks) and Shane O'Bree (25 possies) were good and 'Neon' Leon Davis (25 disposals, a goal) always looked dangerous. John Anthony and Tarkyn Lockyer bagged 3 goals each, doing some handy finishing work. For the
Ladder after Round 11
Pts. % Next Week
St. Kilda 44 183.3
Footscray 28 116.0 Port Adelaide (Marrara Oval, Sat. night)
Carlton 24 117.0 St. Kilda (Docklands, Fri. night)
Collingwood 24 107.7 Bye
Hawthorn 24 98.5
Port
------------------------------------------------
Essendon 20 94.0 Bye
North Melbourne 16 78.9
West Coast 12 87.2
Fremantle 12 79.7 Bye
Cheers, Tim.
The AFL Review is sent via an automatic email list. To join or leave the list is easy.
Please visit our website at http://www.footy.com.au/fts/newsletters.htm
OR
If you have difficulty with the above please email lists@footy.com.au